McNulty said we are paying 40% more than we ought for privatised rail. No other EU country has privatised as fully as we have. UK has the most expensive fares in the EU.

Adrian Martinez, Edinburgh

Bring back British Rail.

Beth Moseley, Norwich

As soon as possible.

Shaun Lowthian, Liskeard

Please bring back the unified system that made so much sense and ran a much better service.

Anna Doughty, Conwy

I want a modern, forward-thinking, streamlined national rail service which serves the public – not one which causes so much stress and confusion.

Jeanette Lowe, Sheffield

Poor services and no pride in the private industry. Bring back BR.

Liam Mills, Portsmouth

Re-nationalise the railways. Renew East Coast’s contract to continue running that service in the interests of the people of this country.

Ben Burman, Radlett

Re-nationalise now. Public ownership is the only way.

Martin Curtis, St Ives

I love nationalised trains.

Jeremy Evans, Brighton

The disconnect between infrastructure and operations and financial inefficiencies across the unnatural boundaries is plain daft.

Brian Reid, St. Neots

The only way to control prices is for profits for the railways themselves, not foreign shareholders.

Daphne Gilbert, Stocksfield

Nationalise the railways and let us have affordable, efficient trains again.

Lois Bennett, Doncaster

As an ex BR employee and First employee I think the railways should never have been privatised. They cost far less to run when they were BR.

Mike Devane, St Neots

Rail privatisation was madness in 1993 and remains madness in 2013. A massive public subsidy of private profit. Re-nationalisation is not just sensible, it is essential.

Julian Wagstaff, Edinburgh

British Rail should never have been stolen from us in the first place. Lousy Tories.

Charles Hemingway, Barnsley

Two private companies have failed with East Coast, yet the government owned set-up returns a profit. East Coast proves the case for nationalisation.

Paul Kerr, Edinburgh

The system was miles better under the old public British Rail. The franchise system in my opinion is just a shambles.

Barry Marshall, Sheffield

This makes sense.

Robert Brook, Dunstable

Keep British Rail as one.

M Spencer, Lutterworth

The trains are overcrowded, overpriced and cost the tax payer more than when nationalised. They used to be a bit scruffy but at least you got a seat.

Kay Hallam, Tadley

I’m sick and tired of paying through my nose for a pathetic and unreliable service on C2C. I’ve had enough.

Francois Calitz, Purfleet

Re-nationalisation of railways is easier than other privatised industries because at expiration existing franchises can be transferred to Directly Operated Railways.

Paul Reddy, Wirral

Bring back cheaper fares.

Damian Roberts, Wrexham

You know it makes sense.

Frances McNeil, Leeds

Bring back British Rail.

Jools Johnston-Elliott, Faversham

Take it back into public ownership ASAP.

Gordon Carey, St Albans

We need a rail service that provides service – not expecting a wheelchair user to push herself onto a platform up a slope.

Anthony Turtle, Hastings

In France, we are about to make the same mistake. The railway to the people.

Joshua Dessapt, Lognes

Although not a commuter, I travel on the line into London all the time. I have a Network card and put it to good use but it’s become increasingly less fun to go into London.

Ray Smith, Luton