Insane that a major infrastructure service is not owned and run by the public. Successive UK (and now Scottish) governments continue to misjudge the public’s view.

Ian Buchanan, Stonehaven

Why should private rail operators who make huge profits and rip us off with high fares receive much higher subsidies than British Rail did? It’s daylight robbery.

Sue Caro, London

It shouldn’t be cheaper to fly domestically over rail travel.

Zach Lines, St Albans

Will a mainstream party have common sense enough to adopt this policy? Why are they so scared?

S Read, York

The public sector is the only credible and efficient owner of East Coast mainline since privatisation was forced on the system.

Rod Stapley, Newcastle-upon-Tyne

Public transport needs to be affordable and it’s not. Let’s stop paying private shareholders and bring British Rail back.

Cora Luscombe, Taunton

BBBR. Except this time make it accountable to a committee of the travelling public, railway experts, successful business people, and no politicians. Thank you.

Hugh Tonks, Cambridge

Another Great British institution trampled on by fake profiteering. Shame.

James Masters, London

No to privatisation.

Henry Sherridan, Doncaster

If we brought back BR we as taxpayers would have less subsidy to pay and cheaper fares.

Roy Smith, Saltburn by the Sea

Private sector vultures have destroyed the railways. We will take them back by force if necessary.

Barry O’Toole, Liverpool

Although I am only 25, I still have fond memories of rail travel being an acceptable form of transport. Fast forward to 2013 and it’s an absolute joke. Bring it back.

Michael Morgan, Plymouth

I’ve had enough of this privatised rail charade, costing taxpayers more and more. East Coast Direct Rail is the right approach. Re-open strategic lines, e.g. Oxford-Cambridge.

David Eldridge, Wallingford

Let’s bring back public ownership under a new model – employees, taxpayers and customers with real power to make decisions.

David Whyte, Liverpool

Kingston-upon-Thames.

Grace Kennedy, London

The only recent franchise that ran on time and made a profit was one taken over and run by the state.

Anita Smith, Mirfield

Privatisation has made British railways the joke of Europe.

Mik Konstantinou, Christchurch

Leave East Coast rail alone with Directly Operated Railways.

Derek Ashton, Brighouse

I object to paying for infrastructure that private firms will profit from. Public investment should support public services.

David Leigh, St.Albans

I agree that we the people need to take it back from private ownership.

Chris Crossley, Sheffield

I fail to understand how anyone could say the railway has improved in the hands of these private companies.

Russell Butler

Un-privatise is the only way forward from this mess.

Dennis Hart, Manchester

The tax payer should not pay for foreign companies to make a profit whilst operating at the highest prices in Europe.

Richard Stainton, Hinckley

Re-nationalise the rail. Make it so it can stand on a par with Europe. Cheap and efficient.

Catherine Lowe, Bedford

The problem with privatisation is the amount of money going out of taxpayers’ pockets into those of shareholders.

Derek Sands, Harwich

Bring it back and let’s run the service for all the people and not for the profits for a few. Think of what good all that money could do for the industry and more.

Steve Fishwick, London

Let’s have a rail system that works for all our citizens and not large profits for a small number of people.

Joe Kent, Leeds

Bring back nationalisation of the railways. The evident failure and cost to the nation has been a false economy. It should just be taken back by the country.

Helen Robertson, Lancing

Privatisation is a complete rip-off – it’s nothing more than selling to the public what it already owns. It’s time for accountability for public services to be restored.

Kevin Alderson, Newcastle-upon-Tyne

British Rail should be owned by the people.

Dawn Price, Nottingham