A railway is a social service and should be not-for-profit, at the lowest possible fares for all. Britain’s railway system is too expensive for many buying on the day.

Dr Adrian Morgan, Ripon

The responsibility for our railways should be in one hand and accountable to the people.

Anna Harrison-Melville, Ashford

I think it is time the government re-nationalises the railways. We need real nationalisation, not the ‘Great British Railways’ nonsense.

Ali Nariman, Leatherhead

Much of our railway system is nationalised – but to continental countries rather than the UK.

Peter Griffiths, London

Far more cost-effective than the present arrangement.

David Carter, Wakefield

Commuting on modern trains costs more than driving. How can this be moral? Privatisation was a horrible mistake and should never have been done.

Jayne Carter, Weston super Mare

The state of National Rail is absolutely appalling.

Bree Allen, Harrogate

This should be done after the next general election. Bring back British Rail – that would make jobs and be better for everyone.

Graham Bowden, Ashford, Kent

Essential services should be run by the public for the public. Profits and subsidies should be ploughed back in and not go into the pockets of private investors.

David James, Leeds

Fares have become too expensive. The railways should work for the benefit of the community, not to reward shareholders. Customer service at the moment is non-existent.

Richard Carnill, Worthing

Privatisation was never the right idea.

Jeff Fox, Huddersfield

Let’s have one form of transport in this country run properly please.

Loretta Pattison, Street

Despite the curly sandwiches, they still provide a cheaper and more efficient service.

Charlie Sutherland-Boyce, Livingston

No compensation for any of the companies currently running the railways. They’ve had quite enough already.

Peter Stoodley, Bradford

How could anyone have tried to privatise, and make what is a core service to the nation a profit making industry? Now there’s a good idea to make it all go wrong.

Eriks Teteris, Reading

East Coast has shown the way – now let’s see the politicians follow.

Mike Vyvyan, Scarborough

Should be non profit making Any profit ploughed back into the business.

Marilyn Riches, Portsmouth

I am old enough to know how good our rail network was when it was a public service and a critical part of our infrastructure. It’s about time we returned to that ethos.

G Hanham, Berwick-upon Tweed

They should never have been privatised in the first place.

Jack Holden, Barnsley

We need one rail system for simplicity, convenience and efficiency, not the profit-oriented system we have.

Chris Mandaza, Birmingham

The present railway system is an grossly over-charged and poorly staffed system that only puts profits before people. Re-nationalisation now.

Kevin O’Connor, London

It is now a privilege to commute. I want this to change for me, my family and my community!

Jack Christie, Aberdeen

I really do not agree with ridiculous rail prices any more.

Lee Bryer, Grays

Privatisation has not worked.

Perryn Biggs, Oswestry

No more subsidies to fat cat franchise owners. We need a public transport system fit for public use.

Andrew Remedios, Brighton

Arriva UK’ is a subsidiary of ‘Deutsche Bahn’ and is entirely owned by the German state: So yes, the UK government does believe in nationalisation but by anyone but us.

Roger Philpott, Cheltenham

Strategic transport planning has given way to a farcical face-saving exercise. Rivals competing on the same tracks will never work.

Paul Burgess, Caerphilly

It’s about time people over profits was something we hear every single day in politics.

Carl Nickson, Liverpool

We are nothing but cows being milked dry. The British railway network is now nothing more than a private business with quarterly targets to meet at the expense of commuter.

Matt Wynne, Leeds

It has been proven that a privatised railway is neither efficient nor reasonably priced. Put it back into public ownership.

Joy Edwards, Codsall