A re-nationalised railway will bring back sensible fares, accountability and a secure and happy workforce. Who can argue with that?

Hannah Dewhirst, Oxford

Time to get value for the daily commute. That’s the way to go.

Charlotte Fregona, Harpenden

Privatisation is a pathetic failure for ordinary people. It has just made the rich even richer.

William Weller, Wigan

The exaggerated expense of tickets makes cost of travel into London unwieldy, impractical and expensive for those too poor to afford such services.

Joshua Flynn, Chelmsford

Rail travel should be state-owned so fares remain low, thus car use is reduced and the government is accountable for safety. Profit shouldn’t come into it.

Catherine Markey, Cambridge

Privatisation was a huge mistake. A re-nationalised railway would be much better as long as the government invests the money needed.

David Whalley, Oldham

The private rail companies are getting more subsidy than BR ever received. They get compensated when things go wrong. They cannot lose. Time to renationalise.

Stephen Atkins, Edinburgh

Progress hasn’t been made with privatisation, just big mistakes like the Virgin franchise. BR was when we had and are going to get real progress.

Jack Plumb, Colchester

I hope the railways do become nationalised. Privatisation is not favourable to the everyday commuter nor frequent travellers like myself.

Sheila Brown, Alnwick

The last train journey I made was a nightmare and the toilets were broken and/or filthy.

Charlotte Moncrieff, Brighton

The franchising and ticketing for privatised railways is ridiculous. Bring back British Rail which my father worked for many years.

Patricia Steeden, Watford

Trains are the best.

Penny Jones, Pembrokeshire

The public service network – trains, roads, cycle lanes and buses is basically rubbish, badly run, expensive and always late, It needs laws to improve or sack those running it.

Steven Wood, Goole

UK railways are in total meltdown. Bring back British Rail, please.

Neal Deakins, Louth

Only public service can deliver a service with the public not shareholders in mind.

Martin Cummins, Edinburgh

All industries back to state-owned please.

Anne-Marie Curry, London

Stop the fares rip-off getting stupid.

Jordan Smith, Bristol

It simply hasn’t worked for the people who use the service.

Ianwit Thorpe, Torpoint

The service provided by Chiltern is woefully inadequate. Clearly not enough resources are allocated to developing infrastructure.

Clare Simmonds, Beaconsfield

Bring back British Rail.

Ieuan Berry, Newport

It’s great that we finally have a forum to help put an end to this crazy state of affairs that is rail privatisation.

Stephen Millership, Stockport

This is a no-brainer. The reasons for re-nationalisation far outweigh the crass commercial arguments for private ownership, especially since that is mostly foreign.

David Tyler, Abergavenny

Do it and win the election.

Roy Charman, Tretower

It’s simply not possible to deliver effective services to stakeholders whilst maximising profits for shareholders. All the evidence available proves this point. BBBR.

Katrina Dorman, Liverpool

If the railways are publicly owned there is always someone to actually take responsibility, otherwise each privately owned section passes the buck.

Bernie Ward, Torquay

21st century and our transport system is a shambles. There’s a lesson here – if it ain’t broke don’t fix it. Definitely don’t sell it.

Victoria Maclean, Telford

We should be supporting our rail network not other ones in Europe.

Kevin Spice, Maidstone

For the sake for of the environment, and because the railways should be a service not a money machine.

Julie Wilkinson, Stockport

People not profit.

Andy Gordon, Sheffield

Glad to be a part of this movement. British Rail must be re-instated, no ifs or buts.

Bill Duckworth, Chipping Norton