The privatisation of public services experiment is an unequivocal failure. It’s time to take it all back.

Kim Grais, Leeds

It is so financially obvious (which is very important to this government) that further comment really is not needed. Wake up Labour Party. We all hacked off on this one.

John Hindhaugh, Gateshead

Privatisation benefited the very people who controlled the government that was in power at the time and we are now sadly seeing the results.

Mike Friend

Over the last year I’ve been unable to take the train when I’ve needed to due to cancellation, strikes and malfunctions. It’s insanely expensive too.

Thomas Butler, Horsham

I am outraged that East Coast Trains been handed over to Virgin/Stagecoach.

Kate Betney, Edinburgh

I travelled with British Rail for many years and it was always good value and the best service. They should have left British Rail alone.

Jennifer Gray, Selby

The only way for success and decently priced rail transport is as one. It shouldn’t have been disbanded.

Pamela Lake, Birmingham

Rail privatisation had everything to do with deluded ideology and nothing to do with efficiency or public service. That wrong needs to be righted as soon as possible.

Peter Chester, Saltburn-by-the-Sea

Please could we have a national rail system that works for the passengers and not for those who are motivated by making money from it.

Sarah Macdonnell, Redhill

It is absurd that a public service is in the hands of those whose sole interest is their own profit.

Maria Dolores Moreno Manzano, London

So we gave it a go and it failed us all. Bring back British Rail.

Jamie Robertson, London

Rhaid inni fod fel rhannau o Ewrop sydd a thrennau rhad sydd wedi eu rheoli gan y llywodraeth. (We need to be more like parts of Europe which have cheap state-run trains.)

Gwenno Dafydd Williams, Cardiff

It’s time to return to Social Democracy.

Michael Hare, Warrington

I believe in nationalised railways to make them fairer for all users.

James Paton, Manchester

How can it be that when the Government has all the best possible resources in the country available, it still pretends that it is better to privatise everything?

Rod Stephens, Ware

It should never have been privatised and would cost less back in public hands.

Jessica Foster, Sheffield

It makes sense to me.

Faith Bennett, Bristol

Re-nationalisation is free at the point of contract renewal, and overall the franchises can make a profit. Keep infrastructure safe from vulture capitalism.

David Roberts, York

I hate Avanti West Coast.

Jerome Jerish, Kendal

Make sure it is run like East Coast is now.

Anne Johnson, Selby

I am old enough to remember the propaganda about state subsidies to inefficient nationalised industries. Now those subsidies have tripled under privatisation.

Stephen O’Neill, Liverpool

Fares need reducing and additional carriages added during busy periods. Passengers having to pay for the privilege of standing for the entire journey is simply wrong.

Su Bradley, Folkestone

Taxpayers subsidise the private rail companies so that shareholders can have dividends.

Charlie Werner, Sandford

Let’s bring back British Rail and lower prices for tickets, as private companies are charging way too much to travel to places.

Leanne Green, Hyde

Privatised BR – one big transfer of taxpayers’ money into private hands.

Peter Hethershaw, Sheffield

I’m sick of paying through the nose to be transported like cattle!

Phil Robinson, Lancashire

I fully agree, the government needs to stop creating private profit on everything. The railways are there to support the economy, not necessarily directly create the profit.

Steve O’Connell, Farnborough

You know this makes perfect sense.

James O’Grady, Coventry

Privatisation has been a farce. The sooner British Rail is re-nationalised the better for all.

David Hamilton, Southampton