Privatisation has only allowed for the highest rail fares in Europe, very limited competition on an infrastructure still paid for by the taxpayer. Value for money?

Gareth Valentine-Saunders, Ripon

Billionaires don’t listen to anyone’s words but their own. Is there any point to this? Derail the City of London if you want social justice.

Steve Anderson, Bristol

Fares are too expensive under private control. Improve the service by investing money into the network directly and not into scandalous salaries and bonuses.

Pedro Pereira, Milton Keynes

I am not a socialist, but I think that such important services should be in the hands of the people and not in the hands of those that seek profit.

Dean Morrice, Bristol

Why should private rail operators who make huge profits and rip us off with high fares receive much higher subsidies than British Rail did? It’s daylight robbery.

Sue Caro, London

I just hope that the politicians accept that the current system would improve if it was just one company with proper accountability. Gas, electricity and water are the same.

Martin Rowlands, Widnes

Bring back British Rail.

Liam Sheerin, Brighton

Bring back a cheaper, cleaner and more reliable service.

Giles Hannaford, Shrewsbury

Rhaid inni fod fel rhannau o Ewrop sydd a thrennau rhad sydd wedi eu rheoli gan y llywodraeth. (We need to be more like parts of Europe which have cheap state-run trains.)

Gwenno Dafydd Williams, Cardiff

Privatisation has made our railway one of the most expensive in Europe per passenger mile. It’s been a disaster.

Anthony Stanton, Cambridge

Our rail service is very unreliable, expensive and non-too-clean. I would like it to be run for the users, not shareholder profits.

Susannah Lord, Norwich

Privatisation of the railways was a huge mistake. They should be in public hands.

Mike Macneil, Newport, Nova Scotia, Canada

I’m sick to death of Tory-inspired rip-offs.

Mazhar Asghar, Leeds

I have stopped using the railways. It’s just too stressing an experience at all stages from booking to travelling.

Stephen Barstow, Malvik, Norway

A national network needs a national and public organisation.

Alasdair Wilson, Newcastle-upon-Tyne

It’s outrageous the price I have to pay a month just to get to work. Every year it gets more and more expensive and the service gets worse.

Malcolm Smith, London

No public service should be run for private profit as it can never serve people’s interest.

Chris Moon, Bridgwater

The current railways are terrifying.

Paul Hebden, Leeds

Please re-nationalise our railway lines.

Dave Devaney, Liverpool

They should never have been privatised.

Dave Oldfield, Brighton

I want a rail service that efficiently runs cheaply for the public, not an overpriced service that is unreliable.

Edward Grassby, London

Private good – Public bad. It’s Orwellian.

John Butler, New Malden

We need one company to oversee the whole of the UK network. Franchising isn’t working. Any profits need to go directly to improving and greatly expanding the network.

Dael Gabriel, Torquay

All public transport should be counted as a utility and all utilities should be re-nationalised.

Frank Evans, Chesterfield

Southern Rail are an utter disgrace. Bring back a rail service that actually serves the public rather than lines private pockets.

Angela Breen, Reigate

Get more commercial transport back on the rails and off our roads.

David Fox, Chesterfield

There is no valid reason for keeping the railways in private hands. The model has miserably failed. This is resulting in underused transport rail service and clogged roads.

Neraj Sharma, Milton Keynes

May I, as a trainspotter, agree that British Rail should come back. Privatisation has gone mad. British Rail for life!

Mason Bennett, Hull

The profits made by the train companies are subsidised through the public purse. If we’re paying for this anyway, why don’t we own it?

Neill Grant, Derby

Let’s keep on this. It’s so relevant and the trains are so expensive compared to Europe.

Barbara Ann Spencer, London