Our railways are a disgrace now, expensive and too full of people to be safe, unless you are in first class.

Julie Grigg

I work on the railway and getting ready for retirement but have always thought it should be British Rail. There’s too much emphasis on profit, not on customer service.

Kate Foster, Rotherham

Please let us have a train system that a modern country like ours deserves.

Giles Long, St Albans

Please make British Rail about safely transporting people again. It’s all about companies making money now.

Dominic Beaman

It should never have been sold off in the first place.

Keith Hitchings, Queenborough

Trains are public transport. It is obscene for a private company to run them for profit.

Mark Dawson, Carshalton

Let us all have our railways back in public ownership. A Labour government might help.

Nigel Dallison, Anglesey

Open more branch lines too, and forget high speed trains with massive costs. Just arriving on time is OK.

W S Stevenson, Weymouth,

Privatisation of the railways was a big mistake. Let’s have an unfragmented system that really works.

Ian Thompson, Newcastle-upon-Tyne

Keep British Rail ours.

Margaret Havercroft, Harrogate

To divide the railways into different companies makes a cut in responsibilities at the weakest point of the railway ever – the point between wheel and track.

Pierre Ofzareck, Cologne, Germany

Spending £100+ to get to London is extortion.

Conor Dunne, Leeds

Stop putting money into the pockets of the greedy privatised railway owners.

Stevan Hezseltine, Carshalton Beeches

Public transport has no place for spivs. It is a basic human right.

Kath Lockhart, Sedbergh

I support this totally.

Gary Taylor, Epsom

A unified national network run in the interests of passengers can only be better than the current fragmented system run in the interests of private profit and bureaucrats.

John Marsden, Lochgilphead

We’re being subject to legalised robbery. HS2 will bring more of the same. Fat profits and a service priced for the rich or on expenses.

John Keith, Appleby

Please stop rail profits from going to non UK corporations and being used to subsidise non UK rail fares and investment in others’ infrastructure.

Andrew Lombardi, Eastleigh

Yes, yes, yes! I favour bringing back British Rail.

Muhammad Rajput, Birmingham

Other countries prove that railways can be run efficiently. This government does not have the right to keep dishing out franchises to private speculators.

Garry Rogers, Southampton

Too much of our country has been sold off without consultation with us.

Sandra Cotterell, Ross-on-Wye

Learn from past mistakes, i.e. the previous privatisation didn’t work. Why repeat the exercise?

Sue Clark, London

British Rail should never have been privatised in the first place. Bring ownership back to those who pay their taxes.

Ann Ferguson, Tyne and Wear

We need to take back control of our railways, so we get cheaper rail fares and better service.

Janine Gallagher, Huddersfield

These companies are virtual, so it wouldn’t cost much to take them back. Get on with it.

Francis Valentine, Edinburgh

Modern train travel is not what it should be, with high fares, delayed or cancelled trains, overcrowding and so it goes on. BR was not perfect but at least they tried.

Mike Gordon, Barnstaple

The splitting into private companies was a disastrous mistake. Reverse it.

Amyan Macfadyen, Sheffield

Amber Rudd is trying to kill our local rail route to implement another even more corrupt, private, expensive disservice in order to kill our town.

Em Law, Hastings

I miss British Rail.

Sue Budd, Falmouth