I actually remember British Rail and, although not perfect, it made co-ordinated travel more easy,

Rose Nugent, Darlington

Privatisation does not bring automatic success. Look at G4, for example. It usually means increased prices and poorer service.

Betty Eade, Leeds

Why should taxpayers subsidise these private companies in order for their shareholders to gain. Take them back now.

Christine Rogers, Hastings

The railways were run much better when British Rail ran the service and didn’t keep putting the fares up.

Sharon Baynham, London

GNER, National Express and now Virgin Trains have ripped off customers on the East Coast Mainline, a service that was profitable and functioning fine until it was sold again.

Jon Veal, Newcastle-upon-Tyne

Greedy, inefficient and monopolistic. That’s the reality of UK rail companies. Enough is enough. We want regulation and a state investment in our transport.

Amy Smith, Dartford

It is time to end rip-off fares, poor service, delays and overcrowding. The East Coast Main Line success shows it is time for re-nationalisation. People before profit.

Nicholas Koopman

Why does it cost seven times more to get a train from Barrow to London than it does to get a plane from Manchester to Spain? This is unacceptable.

Andrew Clark, Barrow in Furness

We have to do something. The way the railway is run now is a total shambles.

David Hardy, Chester le Street

Forget HS2. Look at the unused, existing track bed infrastructure. Endless possibilities exist to reopen our original rail network, for tourism, freight, etc.

Ron Barrett, Gloucester

Commercial organisations should not be permitted to run essential public infrastructure. They favour profit over customer needs.

Daniel Honer, Chelmsford

We are gradually losing many facilities that used to be exclusively British – let’s keep this one, at all costs.

Jennie Cummings-Knight, Cromer

Open the line to Aberystwyth from Carmarthen.

Gwylon Phillips, Aberteifi

Give us back our railways from the fat cats that are only in it to filter the good parts. Get all the land back from their pals in government. Give it back to the public.

William Docherty, Greenock

Re-nationalising the railways wouldn’t cost as much as it does now. The public should be made aware how much the Scottish/UK governments subsidise the railways already.

Karl McAreavey, Glasgow

The railway system is now totally disjointed and run for the benefit of the rich. It’s a national asset and should not be in the hands of private business or foreigners.

Ian Young, Musselburgh

I’m tired of the privatisation mantra. The market does not create efficiency or keep prices in check. Re-nationalise rail now.

Robert Bayley, Ely

Privatisation is not working. Why should our railway be in the hands of foreign state-owned organisations?

John Wright, Salisbury

We need continuous long-term investment in our rail services and the only way to achieve that is through public ownership.

Alison Gibney, St Albans

This debt amounts to theft of the public’s money.

Tony Trodden, Middlesbrough

Public service needs to be resumed, not setting targets as a priority with trains running fast to their final destinations and passengers made to wait for the next service.

Chris Williams, Bromley

Railways should be for the benefit of everyone not just for shareholders. It isn’t meant to be a private profit-making enterprise.

Meg Clements, Newton Abbot

Privatisation created structures that seemed designed to fail. The same investment in British Rail would have given us a service to match European services.

Kay Labon, Southampton

It’s time to get goods transported by rail again and help free up the congestion on the roads.

Carolyn Day, Nottingham

Let’s make it the end of the line for Branson, Stagecoach and all the other shysters who are ripping off the travelling public.

Bert Schouwenburg, Walthamstow

Yes, bring back BR. I worked as a guard on BR for seven years. Today I have never seen it so bad. It’s terrible due to the Tories yet again.

Stewart Bloomfield, Stevenage

Rail services should not be left to the mercy of shareholders. We need to re-nationalise for the benefit of all commuters.

Greg Davies, Slough

Return railways into public hands, so that profits can be returned to the railways to improve services rather than the money going to shareholders.

Allen Teare, Bishop Auckland

A railway is a social service and should be not-for-profit, at the lowest possible fares for all. Britain’s railway system is too expensive for many buying on the day.

Dr Adrian Morgan, Ripon