Northern Rail are the pits. For goodness’ sake, give our railways back to the people of Britain.

Neil Pritchard, St. Helens

Re-nationalise the railways, buses and long distance road transport. Create an integrated network for freight and passengers to meet the needs of the 21st Century.

Tom Stringfellow, Preston

All national infrastructure and any business too big to fail must be owned by the nation and run for the benefit of its citizens.

Richard Gillett, Sheffield

British Rail should be for the people not a get rich scheme for Cameron’s cronies.

Clayton Tindle, Worksop

This might help to stop strikes.

Alison Harte, Kent

What about the Post Office and Royal Mail?

Susan Gassaway

Privatisation clearly doesn’t work.

Neil Tattersall, York

Stinky dirty two-carriage boneshaker trains, overcrowded in summer. Even when the insides are renovated they still leave grime in the recesses.

Colin Telford, Truro

The popularity, price and efficiency of our rail network has deteriorated for long enough.

Simon Oxford, Hereford

I don’t use the rail network since learning to drive but a national rail network/provider seems to make good financial sense as long as it is allowed to modernise.

William Grant, Surrey

Bring back British Rail so that the service is first and foremost for the people, not primarily for private economic profit.

David Sutherland, Montrose

We need investment in an efficient and affordable rail system.

Tony Cook, Lyme Regis

We’ve had enough of companies taking profits and under-investing. All profits, responsibility and decisions should be the Government’s on behalf of the population.

Richard Morgan, Bradford

I couldn’t agree more. Let’s make it happen.

Pattie Barron, Brighton

There is no room for the privatisation of our public transport, health, education and public utilities, just for greedy profits.

Len Clark, London

Northern Rail are a disgrace.

Max Hutchinson, Manchester

I keep telling Miliband it’s a vote winner, but does he listen?

Bob Archer, Barrow-in-Furness

A fragmented rail network makes no sense.

Stephen Butcher, Ballymena

Look at what East Coast brings to the public coffers.

Boris Durham, Leeds

Business and railways don’t mix. As a natural monopoly, there is no real competition amongst providers to deliver a service of good value and high quality.

Matthew Shewbridge, London

Privatisation has been one of the biggest disasters of all time.

Brian Rattray, Aberdeen

Bring the railways back into public ownership.

Howard Ellis, Northallerton

Bring it back.

David Tait, Barrhead

Privatisation was supposed to be value for money. It isn’t. It is a failed experiment and it’s time we ended it.

Julia Callow, Bournemouth

Privatisation has failed us. Why should we give them more money for a poorer service?

George Harvey, Bury St Edmunds

The East Coast mainline has been a success since it was brought back in public hands. The rest of the network can be a bad joke.

Christopher Jack, Edinburgh

Nationalised services are more accountable, therefore provide better service and are more cost-effective.

Rosie Butterworth, Orpington

It is necessary to have a cheap and efficient public transport system (including railways) if we are going to combat climate change.

Peter Robinson, Derby

Transport is infrastructure and should be handled on a no-profit basis by government.

Alex Kashko, Edinburgh

The public funds wasted in private companies is outrageous and could be spent on a public functional railway.

Ben McCullough, Thatcham