I’ve just travelled back from Germany and I am clearly envious of their equivalent of BR. If they can do it, then we can do the same.

Richard Treloar, Portsmouth

The Fat Controller is getting fatter and our trains are getting more crowded, less punctual and far, far more expensive. Re-nationalise.

Glynne Williams, Leicester

It doesn’t have to be a re-run of BR. There are other ways of having a publicly funded rail system – see Germany for example.

Chris Barker, London

Privatisation is an utter shambles.

Ian Walker, Milton Keynes

The train companies are thieves, they steal from the young and thrive off the poverty of the country with an increase in demand – we need to put an end to this.

Jack Gouldbourne, Southampton

You know it makes sense.

Sheila Sheppard, Milton Keynes

Nations depend upon their infrastructures in order to grow strong and healthy. A rail network must be owned by the many not the few because the many legitimise the nation.

Stephen Baldwin, Halifax

Rail is a service, not a profit source for the rich.

David Dowker, Bradford

BR was stolen from the British public in the most heinous crime of the 20th century.

Albert Wm Gosnall, Weston-super-Mare

New Labour proved their closet Tory credentials by not re-nationalising the railways as soon as they were elected in the 90’s.

Jeremy Pavier, Ipswich

I have travelled by train in France and they put us to shame. Building high speed trains will not address this. Just nationalise our railways and improve our system.

Christine Rayner, Leeds

The sooner the better.

Chris Ralph, Great Yarmouth

Please, please can we have our` railway back. It makes sense financially and in terms of organisation and customer service.

Jane Little, Liverpool

I feel trapped in my city, as rail is uninviting and expensive.

Jack Elliott, Leeds

Also, please bring back the T-shirt. It’s a good way of generating comment and raising awareness. Thanks.

Susan Power, Brighton

Prices are ridiculous and the service would just work better if it was run as a whole.

Catherine Crosby, Buxton

End fragmentation, ridiculous complexity, huge hidden subsidies and profiteering now.

Martin Lakie, Worcester

The UK tax payer has subsidised rail companies by £102.68billion since 1985, together with rail fare increases of up to 300% since 2004. It’s a disgrace.

Cyril Fitzgerald, Pontypool

Privatisation does not work. We are still propping up private companies as they make a profit off the back of fed up commuters.

Hayley Wingrove, Wickford

Privatisation has never made anything cheaper or more efficient despite spurious claims to the contrary at its inception, witness the debacle in energy, water etc.

Stuart Tomlin, Rugby

I want to fight the privateers.

Nicola Raymond, Maidenhead

I want value for money: £4,000 a year and no seat.

Lisa Morley, Margate

Parliament has always meddled incompetently with railways.

Robert Hendry, Rugby

A cohesive national rail service that belongs to the people rather than to private operators is what is needed. Currently it is disjointed and expensive.

Sue Edwards, Cheltenham

The fact that the East Coast Mainline can run well at less of a cost to taxpayers shows how rail privatisation is conning us all.

Graham Armfield, Woking

A uniform train regulation and pricing structure please. Trains for people, with enough carriages and enough seats and a reliable service.

Helena Rockett

The privatisation has been a sham and a travesty.

Colin Ives, Wigan

Bring it back into public ownership and expand. Roll back Beeching’s cuts. Isle of Wight needs a light railway desperately. Its been strangled by lack of a good railway.

Peter Jeffries, Isle of Wight

Every ticket is overpriced so no wonder rail travel is decreasing.

Nick East, Stroud