There are certain things that should be owned by the state and not run for profit. Transport is one.

Dave McCrossen, St Neots

I remember when rail travel was on time, reliable and, above all, affordable. Bring those times back.

Albert Lord, Doncaster

Just look at the fantastic work and profits made by East Coast Trains. If they can do it why can’t the whole network?

Dean Chapman, Bristol

No to private railways.

Matt Chambers, Grantham

Take back our railways. They’re ours…

Margaret Kerr, Wirral

Rail, NHS, Mail. These are core social services and should not be run for profit. Directly Operated Rail has proved this will work.

Simon Pickles, Enfield

British Rail was efficient and customer-focused. The current system is a profiteering shambles.

Peter Reynolds, Birmingham

I’d love to use trains more but, almost every time I do, I’m staggered by the inefficiency and outrageous cost of the service. It needs to change.

Gregg Burnell, Chesterfield

It should never have been privatised in the first place.

Mick Francis, Welwyn Garden City

It’s a great idea. The way it was privatised was absolutely crazy. The railway system should be efficient, punctual and user-friendly.

Reiko Hara, London

I support the idea of re-nationalising the railway system.

Sonia Santana, Bishop’s Stortford

Because the rail network is too important to be left to the market.

Sarah Thursfield, Oswestry

They put the fares up year after year but as a taxpayer I am hit twice as I have to subsidise them as well.

Derek Ramsay, Chatham

Trains have been private most of my life – it’s time for a change.

Elizabeth Matter, Nottingham

East Coast is beating all the private companies. The best European networks are state-owned. Private rail is dear and dangerous.

Richard Symonds, Broadstairs

It makes sense, pays money back into the exchequer and costs less to rail users.

Marc Scheimann, Luton

State-run rail systems are efficient and affordable. Try Deutsche Bahn.

Nigel Ball, Sheffield

Train with standing room only is a joke. Livestock have more rights to travel safely Private companies always check the bottom line and are beholden to shareholders.

Ian Crawford, Leighton Buzzard

Bring it back.

Derek Ansell, Clacton

Let’s get this back to the British people and run properly.

Alan Critchlow

We have had enough. Fix this now!

Danielle O’Hara, Lancashire

Please re-nationalise and invest in competent managers.

David Millar, Stoke-on-Trent

British Rail worked. The current mess only works if you’re a shareholder. Let’s get rid of it and bring back BR.

Steve Duffy, Betws-yn-Rhos

Considering the public already subsidises the rail network 3-4 billion a year, yet fares continue to rise. The entire rail network should be standardised to public good.

Ethan Radford, Nottingham

We live in Northumberland and we want a train.

Janet Ferry, Blyth

ex-Tinsley Diesel Maintenance Depot.

Chris Holmes, Colchester

Bring back cheaper fares.

Damian Roberts, Wrexham

A fragmented network does not work.

Jonathan Stratton, Haltwhistle

Nationalisation is the only solution to the appalling cost and standard of service of the present system.

Adrian Clinch, Broadway

Better for all users, for the economy, for the environment.

Michael Edwards, London