Northern Rail needs to go. Levenshulme commute doesn’t work. The 08:11 is a myth.

Chris Schiele, Manchester

Let’s put the British back and make the railways a state-owned company. Everyone then should be able to afford to use them.

Susan Gulliver, Keighley

We need to own the railways. They were on time, clean and often newly refurbished, and there was cheaper food.

Dee Grimes, Lewes

A new great British Rail is central to the UK being suitable for international meetings at the heart of Europe.

Paul Bright

It seems to me vital that the government understands that the railways are not there for the profit of a few but to keep the UK moving.

Veronica Sims, Bedford

It’s nonsense for fragmentation in so small a landmass. We all prefer train travel in a single network.

Andree Rodriguez-Veglio, Daventry

Re-nationalising our railways is the most cost-effective and operationally efficient thing to do. Private monopolies only work for the shareholders – not the customers.

Martin Davison, Chesterfield

Re-unite British Rail.

Roger Khan, London

Come on. You know it makes sense.

Alexandra Lejeune, Dorset

Privatisation sells the UK by the pound. Virtually all sales have been made under Tory governments. They’ve all but sold the NHS now.

Bernadette Potts, Manchester

We keep subsidising failed private rail companies. Why? Nationalise.

Glenn Dove, Manchester

I’d rather go by train than drive, but the sad fact is the car is far cheaper, even when proportionally factoring in initial price, tax, insurance, fuel and depreciation.

Pete Williams, Southampton

Bring back British Rail. Lower costs and more passengers means more money to re-invest in our railways.

Harold Dixon, Durham

Public transport is for the public good, not private profit

Marcus Bonner, Hitchin

The great experiment should now end. Privatisation has not worked. Talent has been lost as train operating companies now work in ‘silos’.

William Shearer, London

Since privatisation, about the only thing which I can see which has improved is the coffee. Trains are still late, overcrowded and staggeringly expensive.

Shaun Hall, Halstead

Where I live, the cost of a railcard to send a child to school costs a family £600+ a year. No wonder the kids bunk the trains.

Mimi O’Halloran, Deal

It’s time to take back all that was stolen from the British public.

Alex Allardyce, Leicester

Too expensive and too inefficient. How can anyone be allowed to profit from this?

Christopher Thomas, London

Perhaps we shall see some sense when the Cons and the Labour join forces.

Jim Read, Chesterfield

Privatisation of strategic services is an obvious mistake.

Steven Lockwood, Derby

Vital services like NHS, power, trains etc. should be run for the people they serve not for vast profit or obscene bonuses for directors.

James Gibson, Irvine

Ticket prices have ballooned since privatisation, as every player in the rail industry whacks up the profit margins.

Aaron M, East Sussex

The railways could be run more cheaply and more efficiently if they were returned to public ownership.

John Wilson, Sheffield

Unified railway. People before profits.

Lee Berry, Redruth

Privatisation has done nothing but rob passengers year after year. It is about time all essential services were nationalised again and run for the people not shareholders.

Allen Heatley, Newcastle-upon-Tyne

I’m sick of being ripped off. Bring back BR.

David Elliott, Cleethorpes

It’s been long enough to prove that privatisation does not work better.

Rosemary Chaffer, Durham

A disastrous policy implemented for reasons of dogma. Our country needs a proper transport system, not a way of enriching private investors at our expense.

Michal Benzinski, Stroud

They shouldn’t ever have been sold because they didn’t belong to the government of the day. Anything state-owned should be put to a referendum before selling.

Peter Stratten, Cardiff