There is no need for the profit motive in the rail industry, but a socially-owned network cannot return to the pre-90s. We can learn from the privatisation experiment.

Stephen Smith, Hawick

Northern Rail – what a rip off.

Anthony Webster, Newcastle-upon-Tyne

If profits can be made by British Rail, they should be ploughed back into the system, not distributed to the already-wealthy shareholders.

David Sleet, York

Re-nationalise the railways! Proof of the pudding is East Coast Mainline. Nationalisation does and can work.

Clive Glaister, Slough

Let’s do it.

Ian Green, Leeds

BR was excellent.

Ethan Lee, Fife

It costs almost £150 to get from Manchester to see family in Devon. It’s cheaper to fly to Paris. What a joke.

Sam Wahnon, Manchester

This scandalous rip-off of ordinary working people obliged to depend on the railways to commute to work must end. It is legalised extortion.

Joan Fournier, Harlow

Vote Labour. Renationalise the rails.

Harry White, Cheltenham

Privatising the rail network has left the UK in the doldrums. The nationalised networks across Europe and elsewhere have nearly doubled intercity speeds.

Richard Hillier, London

The rail services should be centrally owned and prices standardised. The British rail services should never be owned by another country. Eurostar could be joint owner.

Christine Turner, Stanwick

Definitely bring it back. I’m just fed up hearing about these price hikes all the time.

Christine Maloney, Romford

Cost of 4 weekly oyster cards zone 1-9 is £320+. My rent with all bills included is £470. Travel costs are a disgrace.

Nigel Filer, Watford

It is the right thing to do.

Carol Sage, Alfreton

It is time to bring back what we lost, to the forefront of the railway network.

Samuel Fitzgerald, Caerphilly

They should never have been privatised in the first place.

Kingsley Elliff, Halesworth

Just look to the success of the East Coast mainline once it was out of the hands of private companies.

Ann Frain, Sheffield

Fares have recently increased dramatically in the last few years for no obvious reason and it is ridiculous.

Rosalie Rogers, Eastleigh

Our railways would be much better suited in the public’s hands and not Cameron’s Spiv capitalists.

Gary Clark, Sunderland

The service is better than it was, but hugely overpriced. Even cheap day fares have practically doubled since privatisation.

C. Sanger, Haslemere

As a regular West Coast traveller I am consistently frustrated by increases in rail fares.

David Smith, Stourbridge

Too much money going in the wrong pockets.

Paul Smith, Warrington

Our railway is currently an embarrassment. Forget the shareholders and sort it out.

Matthew George, Penzance

Please put Britain’s railways back to when we had the most efficient railways in Europe, i.e. when they were state run, like the majority of European ones are now.

Richard Lewis, Sheffield

I work for East Coast and it definitely works better re-nationalised, unlike the dark days of National Express.

Karlyn Brydon, Livingston

Returning our railways to national ownership is the only safe way to provide a good train service for everyone.

Jenny Haylock, Brighton

British Rail is the only way.

Colin Smith, Derby

Improvement in rail services – more carriages, punctuality, cleaner / greener trains – is needed now. No more fare increases lining pockets of shareholders!

Janis Cairns, Manchester

Oh please, let’s hope this happens.

Lindis Percy, Harrogate

I find travelling to and from my local station is often interrupted, delayed or cancelled.

Charles Metcalfe, Haslemere