People’s daily commute shouldn’t be left to free market greed.

Nicholas Hayes, Durham

Public services should be not-for-profit. To reduce our carbon footprint, taking back control of rail and offering affordable prices for everyone is the best way forward.

Rob McDonald, Newcastle upon Tyne

Give British Rail back to the railwaymen who know the job, not to a load of greedy shareholders who care only about their bank balances.

Neil Walkling, Bournemouth

We need BR back. Things were so much better. Network Rail are rubbish.

Tony Ches, Birmingham

Former apprentice with BRML.

Ian Clark, Northampton

Believe me, the chaos that is railway in the UK is doing the tourist industry no good at all. It’s complicated and confusing.

Carol Neist, Perth, Australia

The railways are too important to the infrastructure. Stop the rip-off fares. We want it to be fair.

Lynda Trickett, Huddersfield

A new great British Rail is central to the UK being suitable for international meetings at the heart of Europe.

Paul Bright

I want a railway run for the benefit of the British public, not for private train companies to bleed the fair-payers and our tax subsidies dry.

Lee Ballance, Chester

You know it makes sense.

Denise Rhodes, London

Why have separate train and track companies? No wonder passengers, who pay high fares, are being let down frequently.

Lynda Edwards, Norwich

It is high time we started to reverse at least some of the damage that was done to our services by selling them off to profiteers.

Colin Everest, Sherborne

Fragmented privatised railways with these ridiculous ticket structures just make no sense. We need a state-owned rail system.

Kevin Philliskirk, Sunderland

We could even bring back the connecting service.

Peter Wilton, Maidenhead

This scandalous rip-off of ordinary working people obliged to depend on the railways to commute to work must end. It is legalised extortion.

Joan Fournier, Harlow

It may be a step back, but if that’s the only way to make it more user-friendly, and less expensive, then let’s do it.

Raymond Greenwood, Bedford

Bring it back.

Peter Horne, London

East Coast owned by the public was doing fine. The Treasury were getting the profit that will now go to big business. It would be a joy to buy tickets from one place.

Catherine Duckenfield, Doncaster

We need railways that can be a source of national pride. This cannot be realistically achieved through profit-focused privatisation.

Barbara Kennard, Ryton

Railways should be solely under the control of Government and run for the benefit of people and not private profit.

Anne Mead, Tewin

We need a unified system that Whitehall does not micromanage.

Raymond Walley, Bexhill

Bring back the big blue trains.

Donald Hutchison, Penzance

Privatisation just doesn’t work for infrastructure or utilities.

Diane Baskerville, Birmingham

It’s time to stop funding private companies’ profits.

Robin Marks, Ramsgate

Conservatives support National Rail.

Max Grussing, London

The heavily-subsidised private companies just cost more to run as with energy, water and health.

Michael Rand, Lancing

The current privatised system is ludicrous, unless of course you’re one of the people making nice profits. Most of us just need a decent, simplified, efficient rail system.

Janice Jarvis, Saltburn-by-the-Sea

Commuting on modern trains costs more than driving. How can this be moral? Privatisation was a horrible mistake and should never have been done.

Jayne Carter, Weston super Mare

The price of tickets and the excellent service on East Coast Mainline is a model for how we as passengers should be treated.

Linda Norman, Harpenden

Not a panacea, but widely supported and surely better than the current mess.

Richard Marchese Robinson, Liverpool