Privatisation of British Rail was a disaster and the success of the East Coast, now back under public control, only underlines the way forward.

Iain Douglas, Knutsford

If the amount invested in subsidies since privatisation had happened to BR, there’d never have been an excuse to privatise it.

Joseph Pakenham, Glasgow

Even the USA’s train system is a publicly funded one.

Steve Rhodes, Doncaster

Costs on the railways are out of control and the private operators are making artificial profits paid for by the taxpayer.

Thomas John Wheeler, Dyfed

The worst thing ever to happen to this country closely followed by gas and electricity privatisation

Bryan White, Derby

The East Coast mainline focused on the passengers, and returning both profit and other benefits to society. It’s a prime example of how nationalised railways do work.

Kyle M, Aberdeen

Bring it back!

Susan Paget, Glasgow

I have stopped using the railways. It’s just too stressing an experience at all stages from booking to travelling.

Stephen Barstow, Malvik, Norway

We need investment in an efficient and affordable rail system.

Tony Cook, Lyme Regis

A national industry would serve the paying public.

Adam Schofield, Telford

I worked for British Rail until privatisation and did not realise how lucky I was to have what turned out to be good honest managers and colleagues, which came to an end.

Leslie Simpson, Edinburgh

There is enough evidence that re-nationalising the railways would work, so stop the waste of re-franchising our railways.

Mark Parkes, Birmingham

The Secretary of State signed off the NRCoC, which means train companies are exempt from general consumer protection because of the ministerial involvement.

Jocelyn Peacock, London

Privatisation does not work, other than for shareholders.

Hilary Wicks, York

Get rid of the private sector bureaucracy and waste from the national network.

Ivan Merino, Pocklington

I’m travelling every day on the most expensive route in Europe and the service is appalling. There is no justification for this.

Paolo Fantini, St Albans

There has to be a better way to organise our national rail service than as it is now.

Margaret Pitt, London

I’m a long-time supporter and user of East Coast trains. It was a brilliant company. It’s time the whole network was out of private hands.

Peter Harding, Sleaford

Railways are a public good and need to be part of an integrated transport system in public hands, necessary for our country.

Margaret Lewis, Leicester

I cannot feasibly use the trains any more at the absurd prices. It is daylight robbery.

Alex Malone, Bristol

Bring British Rail back under public ownership, and gas and electricity too if you ask me. Power back to the people.

Brian Watson, Rotherham

Re-nationalising the railways will ultimately help the environment.

Daniel Haynes, Halstead

Prices are not justified by service (or distances), nor are the yearly over the odds increases.

Kuba Borucki, London

Privatisation of the railways has been a disaster for rail users with rising fares and the lack of investment that was promised.

Kevin Wilson, Leeds

It can be done, if only there is a political will. Do it for the people of Great Britain.

Pier Hausemer, Salisbury

Living with East Coast Rail has highlighted that the case for privatisation has never been proven.

John McNulty, Newcastle-upon-Tyne

Absolutely. Take our railways back! Common sense, surely? Urgent and so obvious now that we can clearly see the farrago that has emerged with privatisation.

Peter Moore, London

I’m totally disgusted that Virgin and Stagecoach will be taking over the running of East Coast Trains. It’s all downhill from now.

Elizabeth Moffat, Nottingham

Some things shouldn’t be left to an investment gambling ring. The right to travel is one of them.

Ian Thornton, Portsmouth