We should re-nationalise as it is cheaper than state subsidy of private companies who, with a profit motive, will fail the people in providing a good service.

Steven Gibbons, Folkestone

The privatisation was only conceived with one aim – profit for the few. Any fool could see that chopping the network into little bits would seriously undermine its efficiency.

Alan Hopkins, Newcastle-upon-Tyne

Privatisation has not improved any of our services and the fares keep increasing. They are all in it for profit and their customers who have to rely on these services are not served well.

Marie Mcguirl, Clacton-on-Sea

We need more cohesion, lower prices and an upgraded service.

Tom Duffy, Coventry

Sack Southern and Claire Perry.

Nicola Laing, Haywards Heath

Get more commercial transport back on the rails and off our roads.

David Fox, Chesterfield

My father was a driver. I worked the plactform. Traveling from A to B was so easy, but now you have to go by what the provider says. It’s madness.

David Bowie, Portsmouth

The only part that has been privatised is the profit.

Jim Hamilton, Rowley Regis

Taxpayers are subsidising rail companies and paying the highest fares in Europe when many people’s incomes are being cut year on year.

Neil Cameron, Sheffield

A totally integrated system makes much more sense.

Lindsay McDougall, Cramlington

The East Coast proves it can work.

Elizabeth Rickard, Newcastle-upon-Tyne

The East Coast line seems to be running much better now it’s government run. Public transport should serve the public, not shareholders.

Sophia Hale-Sutton, Edinburgh

I catch two trains for my commute, from Ramsgate to Maidstone. The fare have started to become ridiculous. My train ticket costs more than my rent.

Barnaby Wimbush, Ramsgate, Kent

The rail services provided are some of the most expensive, yet poorly run in the world. People are forced to drive for convenience, which is damaging our environment.

Kimberley Parker, New Milton

British Rail belonged to us before the sell-off and privatisation but we want it back nationalised and belonging to us again.

Julia Inch, Enfield

Let those currently running the Great Northern line run the rest of the railways. They are doing a better job than the rest already.

Richard Painter, Waltham Cross

We do it better for ourselves than the rich shareholders will ever do it for profit.

Julie Ward, Durham

Profits from the railways should be going to the Treasury, not to shareholders. East Coast has put millions into the Treasury and should be allowed to continue.

Elizabeth Sheard, Wolverhampton

I’m a regular user of East Coast franchise since 2010 and it’s head-and-shoulders above the rest for service and value for public. Re-nationalise natural monopolies.

Suhail Iqbal, Edinburgh

A fair and cost-effective rail service. That’s all I want.

James Nolan, Liverpool

I have stopped using the railways. It’s just too stressing an experience at all stages from booking to travelling.

Stephen Barstow, Malvik, Norway

Get people back on the trains and off the roads with reasonable fares, it has to be cheaper than forever expanding roads.

Paul Clemens

British Rail belonged to the public and should do so again.

Jane Doubleday, Leicester

Quite simply, the system isn’t good enough and needs to be better. We’re all better than this.

Elizabeth Walker, Haywards Heath

All major utilities should not be run for the benefit of shareholders.

Neil Friend, Aldershot

Rail travel is a public utility that should never have been privatised for profit. Bring back BR.

Paul Stevens, Oakham

The London train system desperately needs improving.

Paul Nelson, London

Privatisation makes no sense. Money from tickets should pay for a better service, not to pay shareholders (and also to subsidise German rail users’ fares.)

Andrew Taylor, Oxford

I would like to see our trains brought back into public ownership. Most of our franchisees are state operated – by other countries!

Helen Dodd, Essex