We need a better service. An incident brings down the whole network.

John Tilley, East Twickenham

Compared to other countries our current situation is ludicrous. The railway should be for the benefit of the people not for the benefit of the corporations.

Sarah Macdonald, Melbourne

If trains are re-nationalised, I believe fares will be cheaper for ordinary people and public organisations. It would be better for health, environment and personal finance.

Kim Fergus, Wirral

All utilities should be run on a non-profit basis. Stop this gravy train for people who have more money than they know what to do with.

Anne Callaghan, Blantyre

Re-nationalisation of railways is an essential campaign to resist government’s intent on breaking up services currently owned by everybody to line the pockets of the few.

Laura Mitchell, Edinburgh

All rail services should be brought back under public ownership, not left to the mercy of corporate profiteers.

John Mills, Bridgend

Kill Southern dead.

Daniel Cotfas, London

We are paying the subsidies so we should own the network.

Miles Stapleton, Worthing

Time to bring back what is proudly British, affordable and fair for all members of staff involved.

Nathan Hosker, Leeds

Great Eastern commuters have no choice of rail companies, so how can privatisation be of any use to this line? Private business always wants to make profits, not run great railways.

Russell Stubbs, Colchester

I prefer public ownership of our key infrastructure, with railways run as a public service, rather than for private profit.

Jan Jesson, Wednesbury

People not profit.

Neil Sanderson, Oswestry

I use Northern Rail every week and they are the worst company in existence, late near enough every time. The trains themselves are near 30yrs old and in a terrible condition.

Gary Clark, Manchester

I love trains. Why oh why was such a lovely industry privatised and now used for profit only? Bring back British Rail.

A S, Glasgow

It shouldn’t cost more to use greener public transport than driving a car the same distance. A British railway would give the profits back into the government.

Christine Sutherland, Banbury

How are we supposed to fight climate change when it is nearly half the price for me to travel by car from London to Manchester, than get an off peak advance train?

Rebecca Armstrong, Manchester

Cost of travel by train has become extortionate.

Ev Marcus, Leeds

In Europe you have high quality train networks under one direction. The UK needs to follow suit.

Dave Emson, Bedale

Need there be a comment? Make rail travel a service again, not a business.

Stuart Roberts, Godalming

Rail travel is an essential part of daily life for lots of us and I believe that this service should be nationalised and focus on service not profit.

Michelle Bates, Leeds

Transport is a public asset, and should be owned by the public. The banks next.

Delwyn Davies, Abertillery

Bring back British Rail.

Sana Nagi, Liverpool

I am passionate about re-nationalising British Rail.

Terry Melbourne, Liverpool

It is absolutely ridiculous that a 2 hour journey would cost above £40 from Sheffield to Oxford, booked a month and a half in advance. Seriously, we need cheaper prices.

Charles Philpot, Sheffield

I wouldn’t go back to the old British Rail, but East Coast demonstrates how a not-for-profit company can still deliver good service and value for taxpayers.

Ian Halsall, Bath

Rail is a natural monopoly and pseudo-competition is a nonsense. Bring back BR.

Alan Harrison, Walsall

It would get rid of the chaos of having several different train companies charging different amounts for the same journeys.

Phil Nicholson, Nottingham

Stop the subsidies and re-nationalise our rail network.

Peter Davies, Liverpool

Re-nationalise our train service.

June Carcsry-Stuart, Edinburgh