The companies running our rails are a joke. The prices we pay for the poor understaffed shoddy service is criminal and something has to be done.

Josh Cranwell, Letchworth Garden City

Put an end to the mess.

Yvan Nadeau, Edinburgh

It is totally unacceptable for Arriva to stop services from Wigan to Manchester Oxford Road, Piccadilly and Manchester Airport with no consultation whatsoever.

Andrew Heathman, Wigan

They should not have been privatised in the first place.

Amanda Child, Broadstairs

Having effectively stolen my share in this national company, the government sold it off to people with enough money to spare, so where is my share? We want it back.

Peter Brewster, St Neots

Proletariats should unite wherever.

Hayden Sellick, Newton Abbot

The railways could be de-privatised at no cost to the taxpayer: just do not renew the franchises. The taxpayer will then make a profit.

Ann Round, Penzance

Bring back our railway – under public ownership.

Barbara Alexander, Bude

Improve the UK quality of life. It helps employment issues by offering affordable transport and affordable holiday transport benefits seaside towns. Everyone wins.

Alacia Gent, Cambridge

The TOCs are inherently dysfunctional – they operate local monopolies with no incentive to improve services, and have no interest in saying a word against Network Rail.

John Paylor, London

Why are we subsidising the fat cat tax avoiders to run our railways? Are we mad or what?

Angela Taylor, York

The railway system should be under public ownership. The East Coast line made a profit that was returned to the public purse, not the greedy profiteers running Britain.

Maeve Watson, Rotherham

They should never have been privatised in the first place, and when BR comes back into public ownership, start the process of bringing the buses back.

Thomas Saunders, Ashington

Railways are the property of the British public like all infrastructure. Utilities should be not owned and plundered for profit by fat cats who pay no taxes.

James Dawn, Gloucester

We’ve had enough of companies taking profits and under-investing. All profits, responsibility and decisions should be the Government’s on behalf of the population.

Richard Morgan, Bradford

Monopoly public services should be in public hands. Our money should be spent solely on the service, not on corporate profits.

David Willingham, Eastbourne

The most expensive and poorly run service in Europe and we’re trying to get people off the roads. It’s never going to happen with such a miserable rail experience that we have.

Karen Reeve, Bedford

The recent East Coast experience has shown that the state could successfully take over all lines again

Ann Cohen, Edinburgh

National travel should be cheap and affordable and subsidised by government. The gains to the economy would more than pay for it in my opinion.

Michele Webber, Colchester

The privatisation was a greedy and doctrinaire disaster. Give us back our railways.

Hugh Ellis, Maldon

Just bring it back. It doesn’t need shareholders. It needs cheaper fares.

Dean Riedener, Pembroke

I’m in favour of a re-nationalised rail network.

Chris Matthews

It’s a good idea as long as the prices are low and it is run properly.

Elizabeth Taylor, Guisborough

South West Trains are a joke, as are many other corporations I’m sure! Bring back the rail system that we were once proud to call our own.

Justin Bailey, Guildford

A re-unified national rail network could lead to greater efficiency and a less complex pricing system.

Joan Vickers, Darlington

Re-nationalise and invest in a national rail service.

Nicola Shepherd, Alton

Transport for the people.

Ruth Charlton, Ilkley

I’d happily pay more tax for a cheaper, more reliable rail network.

Andrew Lyall, London

Given the state of rail travel at the moment: late trains, high fares and little to no innovation, we should bring back British Rail.

Jamie Ward, Crediton

British Rail – the clue is in the name. It should all be under one organisation.

Lyn Mackfall, Doncaster