The rail service should be a viable alternative to car travel but in reality the public are held to ransom by an extortion racket.

Anthony Hopkins, Bristol

As a regular traveller to London to visit family, I have noticed the service is better under public ownership and in profit. This model should be applied to all railways.

David Nicholson, Durham

They should never have been sold off.

Hugh Davies, Aberdare

This government appears to want to privatise anything that moves. Public transport should be in public hands where it serves the people not the profiteers.

Arthur Bond, Frome

I have been priced off the trains. A ticket that cost me £40 to £50 last year is £90 upwards. I could just about afford it. I can’t now.

Amanda Peters, Cardiff

We should have kept it as it was. Fares are too expensive. I travel by road as it’s cheaper.

Stephen Murray, Gateshead

The railways should never have been privatised.

Marion Legge, Nottingham

Fond memories of the days of British Rail. Bring them back.

Steve Alton, Haywards Heath

I am in total agreement with you.

Ian Carruthers, Bolton

And we’re passengers, not customers.

Mark Gregory, Yeovil

The only rail service that makes a profit is East Coast trains. That says it all really.

Helen Taylor, Wakefield

All rail revenues above cost should go back into the rail network, not fat cats’ pockets.

J Taylor, Swansea

Bring back British Rail.

Stephanie Thomas, London

Wouldn’t it be great if Government listened to sense? It’s not a free market, I can’t choose which train I take to work and private companies simply extract profit.

Frank Bainbridge, Norwich

Rail needs a long-term view and long-term significant investment. It’s only possible by re-investing all proceeds into the network. Shareholders drive investment down. Always.

Peter Davies, Hove

Instead of subsidising shareholders, we should be making profits for the benefit of the entire population of the UK.

Jennifer Ross, Bedlington

End this privatisation and give us back our British Rail lines.

Robert H Marshall, South Woodham Ferrers

Wasted money on private franchises – not good value for the general public.

Sandra Hanna, Selby

Something has to be done about this blatant rip-off.

Pete Sherwood, Wallington

They should never have been sold off. It’s now a shambles – private greed and profit put before passengers.

Brian Dempsey, Bo’ness

Essentials like travel and public services and utilities should be run by us, for us.

Carole Williamson, Durham

The present system is crazy.

David Cook, Oakham

I believe that a nationalised rail network would provide a far better service and financial return. Forget how it used to be and do it better.

Bill Stead, Leamington Spa

It cannot be right when trains are more expensive that using a car. Train travel should benefit all the people, not just to make profits for the few.

David Finch, Luton

I’m with you all the way.

Ron Glatter, Hemel Hempstead

The current rail system needs to go.

Amanda Dawes, London

A single state owned but not state run railway – run for non profit and for the people!

David McIntosh, Liverpool

The rail companies monopolise the lines, charging whatever they want.

Julian Gore