I’m definitely in favour of re-nationalising the railway system (what we have left of it in Wales.)

M J Bailey, Carmarthen

Let’s run the railway as a public service not to make private profit.

Philip Cotton, Morpeth

Rail fares in this country are way too much – especially for students living in rural areas where transport is scarce.

Fiona Crompton, Bodmin

Hand out subsidies (from our taxes) to hand them to investors? It makes no sense.

Hugh Gurney, Glasgow

This is the strangest ‘privatisation’ I’ve ever come across. Taxpayers’ money is given to the private firms running the railways to shore up nice dividend payouts.

Margaret McGowan, Edinburgh

It would be nice if Britain also still had some industry left in the form of locomotive and carriage manufacture, instead of having to buy everything from abroad.

Andi

A unified network has to make sense.

Robert Holland, Nottingham

When I was a student I commuted to South Sussex every weekend. This was affordable. Now it would not be.

Hereward Pooley, London

In order to get a joined up approach to routes, safety, running times, rural service etc. – we need nationalisation.

Maggi Bevan, Reading

Better for all. British Rail must be put back into public ownership.

Gary Linney, York

Rail is a necessary public service and should belong to the public.

Kaotuka Raaman, Sidcup

We need a rail network to service citizens not city banks.

Malcolm George, Wakefield

It is clear that the ridiculous increase in train prices each year is for shareholders. Each year my fares go up with no improvement in service.

Grace French, Luton

I have not used the train more than 4 times since it was de-nationalised.

M Lovious, Liverpool

It’s the only way to improve it now.

Paul Carnall, Sheffield

It is just a joke. We knew it was wrong at the time. Do politicians get anything right?

Kevin Guyatt, Stockport

It’s one of those things that will never go away. Re-nationalise the railway system and put down new tracks that were ripped up by the Beeching cuts. It’s the future.

Franca Bruno, Castle Douglas

The companies running our rails are a joke. The prices we pay for the poor understaffed shoddy service is criminal and something has to be done.

Josh Cranwell, Letchworth Garden City

An efficient and affordable train service is vital for the economic well-being of the country.

Nicholas Burman-Vince, London

Return railways into public hands, so that profits can be returned to the railways to improve services rather than the money going to shareholders.

Allen Teare, Bishop Auckland

Let’s get rid of this farce of free market idealism gone too far. The person buying the ticket has no choice but to add to the profits of the local monopoly.

Adam Anderson, Sheffield

It is one area where it makes sense to subsidise public transport for economic benefit in moving the population around safely.

Leslie Reid, Aberdour

I’m fed up with getting ripped off by these big private companies.

James Woodburne, Liverpool

Hopefully re-nationalisation would help end the enormous discrepancy in fares in different parts of the country.

Heather Morton, Grimsby

We bought it – we paid for it – and now we are paying all over again and again – whilst others reap the profits.

Susan Atkins, Sheffield

I worked on the railway for nearly 20 years and it was much better as British Rail than as a private company.

Kathleen Webb, Glasgow

Returning to British Rail would simplify all the Ticket Clerks’ jobs greatly.

John Conley

Bring back British Rail. It should never have been privatised.

Kenneth Phelps, Worthing

It should be part of society and not a money cow.

Charles Scott, Falkirk

Beeching’s rationalised railway made commercial competition impossible as each route is is a monopoly. The only sane way to operate this is as a nationalised entity.

Jo Turner, Leeds