A national railway network should be a national asset. A public transport system essential for taking people to work should not be run for private profit.

Keith Jermyn, Watford

Bring back British Rail – I’ll even have the sandwich!

Simon Thompson, Kendal

Trains for the people not for profit.

Nikki Wood, Todmorden

The last 20 years have been a shambles, not least the Railtrack saga. Service standards on trains have also plummeted, whilst prices have rocketed.

Fraser Paterson, Edinburgh

Public services best serve the public by being publicly owned and run.

Howard and Susan Cheesman, Carlisle

Ticket price variations are too confusing and expensive

Mark Parker, Thatcham

Not tomorrow – now.

Dennis Lane, Middlesbrough

Unite the railways and make it better for customers and staff alike.

Michael Smith, Enfield

All privatisations of publicly-owned infrastructure assets were driven by commercial interests and have not served the public well – an abdication of responsibility.

John Heap, Wetherby

I pay £10.30 for a 30 minute train ride. I never get a seat and I feel ripped off every morning.

Mitch Law, Weston-super-Mare

The present system is costing the taxpayer more than British Rail did.

David Hunt, Nottingham

Re-nationalisation should take place without any compensation to shareholders. They bought what we already own, so should lose their money as if they’d bought a stolen car.

Charlie Monck, Charlbury

The days of Joe Public paying through the nose to sustain the luxurious lifestyles of the greedy capitalist class must come to an end.

Alan Crowther, Stockport

Bring back a unified service as opposed to the fragmentation we have today.

Linda Ash, Hoddesdon

Far too much profit going into people’s pockets, and not enough going back into the British Rail network.

Stuart Malcolm, Penicuik

I am a retired employee of WAGN (12 years) and have seen a lot of change, most by foreign rail companies. In my view the rail system belongs to the public.

William Dudley, Stevenage

Give us back a decent service with reasonably priced tickets.

Catherine McChleery, Coventry

The current system is expensive, confused and dangerously inefficient. It is high time to return it to imperfect but superior public ownership.

Ted Bains, South Shields

Bring back British Rail.

John Robertson, Reigate

Everything in the ‘We are the collective’ statement rings true.

Chris Nicoll, Berwick-upon-Tweed

Nationalise the means of production, distribution and exchange.

Kevin O’Hanrahan, London

I have many happy memories of travelling by train with my father as a child. I would love to see the return of British Rail.

Margaret Stritzel, Derby

A shameful service that gives no consideration to the people who use it or the people who work for it.

Clive Ford, Hove

Bring it back as soon as possible.

Adam Lewins, Doncaster

About ticket pricing. I had to tell USA tourists why I had a saver return ticket with seat (£12) to London & they paid £92+ each to stand.

Margaret Hunt

If they’re charging fares like that, how much are they really making?

Brian Atkins, Cannock

Re-nationalise the railways. They are a public service and can be run more efficiently in the public interest than for private profit.

Paul Greening, Dorchester

Track, facilities, rolling stock and staff should be managed regionally, with overall direction from the centre.

Geoffrey Crouch, Cranbrook

Major hated national rail and privatised it to pay profits to investors and companies. It is an expensive failure for taxpayers and users. Re-nationalise it.

Jacqueline Zylinski, Hereford