This is another example of politicians giving individuals increased power and influence to the unelected. Why?

Wilson Newbould, Livingston

The rail service should be a viable alternative to car travel but in reality the public are held to ransom by an extortion racket.

Anthony Hopkins, Bristol

British Rail, as a publicly owned company, offered an efficient, well-run service with the customer at the fore, whereas privatisation puts monetary gain first.

Diane Edmonds, Grimsby

Public transport should not be run for private profit.

Ray Packham, Bradford-on-Avon

Labour’s GBR plans are certainly a step in the right direction, but are half-baked. Let’s do it properly!

John Hunt, Lincolnshire

I feel that a country as small as the UK should have a unified and properly-funded railway service under state control. Contrast French/German railways with ours.

Fiona Lennard, Glasgow

Train overdue.

Robert Lindsey, London

Railways massively supported the war effort but were never adequately recognised or rewarded in the 20th century. They are a public service.

Kieran Fitzsimons, Newcastle-upon-Tyne

Privatisation did nothing but put shareholders first and customers last. It always has done and always will do.

N J T Lauro, Wirral

I’ve argued long and hard for this since the mid 1990s.

David Henshaw, Dorchester

All essential services should be non-profit. Travel is an essential service and should belong to the people.

John Couzin, Glasgow

They should never have been privatised in the first place.

Clive Hodgetts, Rhyl

Bring back British Rail.

Janet McLoughlin, Manchester

Not just re-nationalisation, but as part of an integrated public transport system tasked with reducing road traffic – and under its real name, BRITISH RAIL.

Colin McDonald, Herne Bay

I spend one fifth of my wages on the worst, totally unreliable, rudest service. They get it wrong all the time, but if you do, heaven forbid.

Rebecca Gould, Cardiff

It just makes sense to do this.

Natasha Richards, Salford

British Rail had class. British rail had its own recognisable railway uniforms. There are too many names now. The name Britain is lost from the industry.

Bradley Ruben, Ilford

The idea is that people get to travel, but who can afford to go anywhere? Surely the economy would improve if it were cheaper to get from A to B.

Mike Kerins, Manchester

BBBR. Except this time make it accountable to a committee of the travelling public, railway experts, successful business people, and no politicians. Thank you.

Hugh Tonks, Cambridge

Aside from the economic case, there is something incredibly romantic about travelling on a railway system that is collectively owned by every British citizen.

Jonathan Brown, London

East Coast trains have greatly improved since they were taken back from the National Express.

Marie Bowers, Dundee

It’s not a service any more.

Terry McKeown, Leeds

Out of all the countries I’ve travelled to, trains are most expensive here. Constant delays, cancellations, charged extra in peak times. All for what?

Terrance Dobbins, Wirral

I think that British Rail should come back. Let’s hope the train fares go down.

Sam Bridges, Derby

Bring back British rail!

Toby Johnson, Wirral

Re-nationalise all TOCs.

Raymond Lockwood, Wakefield

The railways belonged to us before they were sold off. Re-nationalise British Rail and use any profits to re-invest in the infrastructure, not line the pockets of the rich.

Jonathan Gulliford, Merthyr Tydfil

Why can’t we have a rail system as good as many other countries?

Colette Wright, Torquay

If the amount invested in subsidies since privatisation had happened to BR, there’d never have been an excuse to privatise it.

Joseph Pakenham, Glasgow

One rail transit system for all, run for the good of all.

Charles Asbury, Swansea