Not a single privatised, former public sector entity has proved to be a success in anything other than financially benefiting itself at the cost of its customers.

Steve Pearson, Newcastle-upon-Tyne

This needs doing.

K Badlan, Ludlow

Also bring back guards vans so that bicycles can be carried easily. Essential for a super transport network.

Timm Frenzel, Risca

And this goes for the NHS as well.

Lauren Murray, London

Isn’t it time that the government listened to regular rail users and bring back British Rail and stop this privatisation madness?

Jamie Neil, Aldershot

Passengers before profits.

Peter Greenwood, Darlington

Everything that was ever nationalised before Thatcher sold it should be re-nationalised.

Dawn Farrier, Nottingham

Better train transport is vital to cut emissions and pollution and improve accessibility for people outside cities. Profits should be re-invested to develop a bigger network.

Fiona Maclennan, Dunfermline

I love the railways, so please return it to the people out of the hands of the profiteers.

Kenneth O’Connell, Falmouth

Public services should never be privatised.

David Batten, Coventry

I’m embarrassed that the country that invented the railway now needs to live up to the far better nationalised railways of other countries.

Adam Stratton, Winchester

Common sense, public service run for the people, not bankers.

Alison Morgan, Gloucester

And we want clean trains.

John Podger, Ware

Read ‘The Permanent Way’ by David Hare.

Hywel Morgan, London

Privatisation is a right wing ideology that does not work with industries that need to be countrywide and where some areas need to be supported by others.

Bernice Broggio, Gateshead

Private enterprise is failing and is too expensive. Any surplus should go to the Treasury not to shareholders.

Colin Robinson, Gateshead

I joined British Rail in 1983 and am still in the industry today. I can’t believe we pay people to run a service so that they can make a profit.

Dario Giudici, Stevenage

The prices of rail travel in this country are disgusting and something has to be done about it. Cheaper rail prices would mean fewer people driving cars which means a greener country.

James Hobbs, Bristol

Daily commute changed drastically since Abellio took over ScotRail e.g. regular/usually daily delays, cancellations, rarely any explanation; changed timetables, fewer trains.

E Morrison

BR wasn’t perfect, but it was affordable and, for the most part, worked well. The current system of private monopolies is only of benefit to railway company shareholders.

Howard Spencer, Hove

Just re-nationalise it for all our sakes.

Neil Tilstone, Manchester

British Rail should never have been privatised. It was only done for private profit for shareholders.

Alexandra Quinn, Glasgow

If we want to get more people in trains and off the roads we need affordable prices. More passengers legitimise railway investment.

Kimble Perry, Dover

East Coast line has proved that a state-run railway can succeed and make money, so let’s keep it nationalised and extend railway nationalisation.

Margaret Hunt, Doncaster

Bring back British Rail, a real railway service that worked.

Alex Holness, Erith

The rail network is a joke in its current state, and the most expensive in Europe.

James Parsons, London

Why break something that was working so well?

Alison Oxley, Pickering

This isn’t competition, it’s theft. I’m a life long Tory voter, but if Labour fix the utilities they’ll have my vote come the next election.

Mark Beeby, Norwich

For the past months my morning Southern train to Victoria was never on time and you couldn’t get on it as it was way overcrowded. This is unfair. What do I pay for?

Rafael Kowalczyk, London