The service currently being offered by the existing privatised train companies is way below an acceptable standard and too expensive.

Antonia Petale, London

EMR have been so unreliable that a two hour journey now very often becomes five hours. They monopolise the service that is run for profit not passengers. We need better.

Clare Jennings, Nottingham

They should never have been privatised in the first place.

David Kent, Whiston

Frequent travellers need decent fares.

Roxana Anniuk, Philadelphia, USA

I might have to find a new job if the trains don’t improve.

Katy Makepeace-Gray, London

This country needs an integrated and unified rail system run for public benefit not a host of private companies making profit for shareholders.

Stephanie Potts, Norwich

Nationalise ASAP to reduce fares and stop putting money into the pockets of greedy shareholders. Especially Richard Branson.

Ross Curtis, London

BR should never have been sold off in the first place.

Brian Baylis, Village

We must re-nationalise rail – at the moment it is just a charity for the rich.

Graeme Booth, Orpington

BR cost taxpayers about a third of what the privatised railway does now and was cheaper for passengers too. Nationalise franchises when they expire for greater efficiency.

David Sterratt, Edinburgh

It’s clearly sensible.

Sue Ahrens, Watford

The rationale for selling off a national asset – that “competition” would lead to better services and lower prices – has proved to be faulty. Give it back.

Shellie Eyre, Nottingham

The public funds wasted in private companies is outrageous and could be spent on a public functional railway.

Ben McCullough, Thatcham

Privatisation is a disaster. A simple and fair fare-structure and user-friendly service (remember that word?) would make travel better for everyone, including tourists.

Sally Finesilver, Oxford

It should never have been privatised in the first place. Greed once again was put before common sense.

Keith Jones, Gateshead

They should have been brought back years ago.

Robin Banks, London

Fares are much too high, and the service is inadequate. Re-nationalise now.

Vincent Gould, Solihull

The time is ripe to start taking back the railways. A lot of franchises are due for renewal so don’t renew them.

Jim Stroyan, Huddersfield

Lets take back our trains and make them work for us, not private companies.

Deb Tetley, Leeds

Come on. You know it makes sense.

Alexandra Lejeune, Dorset

It’s been a farce since it was privatised. Re-nationalise now.

Adrian Beldon, Huddersfield

As an essential public service, rail transport, along with buses and all utilities, should not be for private profit-making – and certainly not whilst we still subsidise them.

Richard Francis, Brackley

It is galling to learn that privatised Arriva Trains Wales is owned by Germany’s state railways.

John A K Davies, Haverfordwest

It wasn’t broke and now BR needs to be re-nationalised.

John Weeks, Rushden

It’s been no good since privatisation.

Mervyn Collyer, Nottingham

This situation is disgusting with no respect and no dignity.

George Moore, Ardrossan

Profits should go to improvements not to shareholders.

Joan Darling, Newcastle-upon-Tyne

Passengers before profit.

Kara McCormack, Nairn

Privatising critical services does not work.

Harrison Foster, Portsmouth