If the old British Rail had received the financial support now given to the private operating companies we should have a ‘gold plated’ up-to-date railway system.

Barry Kay, Chesterfield

Utilities should belong to the people.

Lee Dalton, Weymouth

It’s not all about profit.

Tony Wilmot, Birmingham

Making profits for shareholders should not be the primary motive for a public transport company. Providing reliable, efficient, safe and affordable transport should be.

Hannah Meese, London

Trains are too expensive and too crowded.

Shirley Cameron, Sheffield

And steam too.

David Reilly, Farnham

Bring back British Rail. Privatisation isn’t working.

Philip Kingston, Woking

Bring back British Rail.

Ashley Sinani, London

Network Rail vs. train companies. Hopeless scheme of penalty fees depending on who caused a delay – what a waste. They should be working together – it’s too fragmented.

Christopher Waterhouse, Oxford

No ifs, no buts, re-nationalise now.

John Moore, Weston-super-Mare

We need a fair rail network that is affordable and works.

Andrew Adam, Norwich

Private it’s theirs Public it’s ours.

Paul Houldsworth, York

Our rail network needs coherence which is not possible with too many privatised bits

Chris and Rosemary Staddon, Nottingham

Travel by rail is overly expensive, complicated, frustrating. The service is poor – trains are late on a daily basis – trains are dirty with toilets frequently overflowing.

Caroline Winn

Let’s put an end to fat profits for Southeastern Trains and a thin service for passengers.

Graham Elder, Gillingham

It would be better off re-nationalised. More efficient, more homogenous and any profits going back to the Treasury.

Ian Buckley, Watford

The current system is too complicated and unaccountable and civil servants would be too involved in micro-management. Let the railway be run by professionals again.

Patrick Adams, Barnstaple

And we’re passengers, not customers.

Mark Gregory, Yeovil

Re-nationalisation of the franchised railway services would be in the public’s interest, as well as being more cost effective for the government.

John Brogden, York

I’m fed up with tickets not allowing you on certain trains. It happens too often to us. We don’t want money-grabbing shareholders taking the profits. Plough it back into travel.

Lesley Homer, Dunstable

British Railways should be for service and not for profit. Enable British success on an individual and national level by promoting affordable, efficient railways.

Louise Marchal, Thirsk

Bring the fares down by cutting out the profit factor and save and create jobs and improve safety. It’s a no-brainer!

Margaret Sharkey, London

The fare rises are disgusting.

Harry Mander, Westcliff-on-Sea

Every privatisation has been a disaster. Beeching was in the pocket of the road hauliers. Bring back our rail networks in state hands.

John Mangan, Norwich

British Railshould never have been lost. We need British Railback.

Robert Whittington, Sheffield

I have to live with Southern Rail every day. They are terrible. I want a system that is primarily about serving passengers, not shareholders.

Ashley Wells, Loughborough

Bring back available, affordable travel for all. Not everyone has a car or can afford one. We all like to get out and about, not just car drivers.

Jackie Ross, Wakefield

Taxpayer money built the rails and now we’re just getting ripped off by the companies that own the concessions.

Marc Brammer, Glasgow

All public transport needs to be integrated.

Paul Nixon, Crewe

Unbelievable ticket prices, huge mark-up and terrible service. Privatisation was a bad, bad idea.

Vaibhav Khullar, London