A fragmented service, owned by mainly foreign companies, charging higher fares than the rest of world for benefit of shareholders not passengers. Re-nationalise it.

Jim Lacey, Holyhead

Bring it back now.

Anne Keighley, Manchester

Make it a partnership: a publicly-owned John Lewis, with passenger, employee and government representation – not a state bureaucracy, as before.

Ian Mycroft, Leamington Spa

I’ve reached the end of the rail with Southeastern. We need a return to a service run for passengers not for profit.

Louise Butcher, Kent

I loved working for British Rail and it was never the same following privatisation.

Greg McGurk, Billingham

I never understood why taxpayers pay private rail operators to take passengers’ money, with no gain to the taxpayer.

Jane Lennie, Shepshed

ScotRail has been taken over by Abellio, an apparently good Dutch company, from First, a crap Scottish company. All British public ownership would seem a better idea.

Margaret Worrall, Aberdour

The rail privatisation has got to be one of the most outrageous, harmful and impractical of all privatisations.

Martin Bedford, Bournemouth

East coast is an example of what a good job a publicly owned rail company can do.

John Davies, York

I’m sick of rubbish expensive trains. The current rail companies couldn’t give a toss as long as they rob us dry.

Rachel Whittaker, Bath

We now have a muddle of over 700 companies, thanks to a stupidly ideological form of privatisation that only benefits big business and foreign governments.

Martin Gough, Hertford

I would rather the public purse profited from a crappy rail service than fat cats and their shareholders.

Richard Sutton, Hexham

British Rail publicly owned would be operating in the interests of the stakeholders.

Hilary Parnell, Rickmansworth

East Coast has shown the way – now let’s see the politicians follow.

Mike Vyvyan, Scarborough

Re-nationalise the railways.

Lee Calder, Birtley

I grew up with British Rail and was not happy when it was sold off.

Rosalind Collier, Bristol

Stop putting profits above people.

Andrew Gays, Leicester

Bring the railways back into our hands and let our economy benefit.

David Roberts, Scarborough

Stop selling our services to Germany and Holland. They wouldn’t like it if we interfered with their railways.

Stephanie Dearden, London

God protect us. Have you ever tried to buy a ticket via the Indian telephone No? It’s a nightmare.

Alan Marshall, Boston

Bring BR back to public ownership, control fares and get more freight onto the railways.

Graham Donaldson, Wakefield

For a streamlined rail experience, bring back British Rail.

Geoff Hayley, Lincoln

Just look at the fantastic work and profits made by East Coast Trains. If they can do it why can’t the whole network?

Dean Chapman, Bristol

People need freedom to move.

Alan Holmes, Stafford

It’s the only way you will ever get an efficient rail system.

Barrie Hood, Newton Aycliffe

While not perfect, public transport in Germany is clearly superior to what we have in Britain. I think that speaks for itself.

Cailean Maclennan, Lanarkshire

You knew where you stood with British Rail.

Helen Flyn, Peterborough

Eastern Rail’s success is surely enough evidence for re-nationalisation.

David L Atkinson, Mirfield

The railways in the UK need to be brought into the 21st century. We need paperless, at cost, reliable travel, not the confusing, expensive and inefficiency we now have.

Ellen Blakemore, Brighton

Affordable travel for all.

Christopher R Wintle, Birmingham