Our fragmented railways are in a mess – expensive and unreliable. We need a nationalised service where all revenue goes back into the service and not shareholders’ pockets.

Barbara Segal, Bristol

I remember the days of British Rail and want them back. I am sick of private companies raking in loads for doing nothing. £1800 a year and I don’t get a seat. Enough.

Georgie Stagg, London

A new British Rail is a commonsense approach for a greener transport system for the UK.

Ahmed Desai, London

Re-nationalise all the rail network and get a grip on the fares and conditions (like overcrowding.)

Douglas Elliott, Sheffield

I find it shocking that when I am abroad (in Europe) trains are so much less hassle, and so much cheaper.

Gareth Tucker, Aberystwyth

It does exactly what it says on the tin.

Nicola Blackwell, Lewes

Privatisation has not benefited the customer. Bring back BR.

Ian Wright, Redditch

I couldn’t agree more. Re-nationalise the railways now.

Mark Bailey, Sheffield

Privatisation was a terrible failure for commuters and a great win for greedy investors.

Steve Andrews, Lincoln

Stop the massive waste of public subsidies to private companies. Let the parasites run the trains out of their own profits or re-nationalise them. Let them be publicly owned.

Lyndon Bent, Hull

It was a mistake to privatise British Rail (although it needed reforms). The results have not been in the public interest.

Simon Archer, York

Rail, NHS, Mail. These are core social services and should not be run for profit. Directly Operated Rail has proved this will work.

Simon Pickles, Enfield

A guard should be placed on every overcrowded train to monitor commuter conditions.

Craig Meyers, Wivenhoe

Like roads, the railways ought to be a national resource not a private profit-making organisation.

Clive Minnican, Felixstowe

Return the railways to the people. Five regions served by real railwaymen. Now they stuff trains in silly liveries.

Alan Smith, Rushden

I totally agree with public ownership.

Andrew Boote, Crewe

Southern’s ongoing failure to provide a reliable service is deplorable. It’s clear the government don’t care about the travelling public and are happy to fund our misery.

John Lucas, Middleton-On-Sea

The present structure is not working for the customers’ benefit. All it does is make the private rail companies loads of excessive profits.

Steve Cowie, Inverness

Private rail is expensive and inefficient, robbing the tax-payers.

George Bell, Gateshead

Passengers not profit, just as it should be patients and not profit in the NHS. Give us back our assets.

Terry Davies, Telford

Enough is enough.

Richard Jones, Plymouth

BBBR Now. Stop the waste of money going to shareholders and out of the railway industry.

Steven Parkes, Glasgow

Privatisation has failed the passengers and serves only the shareholders of the rail companies. Re-nationalised and run efficiently East Coast line shows public success.

Simon Bell, Torpoint

It’s ludicrous subsidising railways with operating companies taking profits out of the subsidy.

John Bibby, Morpeth

I prefer public ownership of our key infrastructure, with railways run as a public service, rather than for private profit.

Jan Jesson, Wednesbury

Privatisation has cost the taxpayer far more than BR would have done.

Nick Sadler, Bristol

I am appalled by the sky-rocketing price of travel, the most expensive in all of Europe. It’s disgusting.

Charles Honderick, London

Selling vital services for profit is a short-sighted disgrace. Bringing back BR would reduce the complexity of our rail network and benefit national transportation.

John Halfpenny, Ripley

All the European countries with fast, modern, efficient railways (France, Germany, Spain, Switzerland etc.) have unified systems. It’s not rocket science.

Peter Bowyer, Carlisle

Please bring back the railways into public ownership.

Lynda Russell, St Leonards-on-Sea