We need a not-for-profit rail network. East Coast has succeeded since being taken out of failing private hands. Bonuses and payments to shareholders put the prices up.

Jean Wilson, Bradford

Bring back British Rail. We need a national rail service as the private companies have made a complete mess of things.

Chris Fry, Kidlington

Railways should be a public service. Period.

Geo. Meadows, Kidderminster

What doesn’t make sense, either socially or economically?

Roger Jackson, York

We must demand that the government takes our public transport needs seriously.

Christopher Madden

Privatisation has made British railways the joke of Europe.

Mik Konstantinou, Christchurch

Support from a railway enthusiast from Beijing, China currently living in York, England.

Zehang Li, York

East Coast Line is the model railway outfit for all UK rail.

Paul White, Huddersfield

£5k a year and you can’t even get a seat on the 7am train to London from Colchester

Gavin Edwards, Colchester

It’s already subsidised so why not re-nationalise?

Daniel Pearce, Ebbw Vale

I’m tired of being over-charged and exploited by my train company. I want fair fares and a service that runs on time – for everyone.

Hazel Willis, Saffron Walden

I have worked within the current system and have seen the franchising farce first hand. Bring back fairness for the rail user. Bring back British Rail.

Sean Neagle, Exeter

I love travelling by train, but it’s become prohibitive unless planned well in advance. The infrastructure is not being kept up-to-date despite huge profits.

Shannon Robalino, Gateshead

All privatisations of publicly-owned infrastructure assets were driven by commercial interests and have not served the public well – an abdication of responsibility.

John Heap, Wetherby

Train users have been ripped off for too long.

Kevin Smith, Bath

We must change the government.

Ann Beal, Holmfirth

Nationalisation is necessary to lower fares and make rail travel more affordable and attractive in the face of the climate crisis.

Gregor McIntosh, Kirriemuir

Economic and reliable rail travel is not a luxury but a requirement for a modern, successful economy. Get rid of the franchises and nationalise the railways.

Ray Laidlaw, North Shields

An innovative transport system built with the shovels, barrows and early graves of our Victorian forefathers – today’s capitalist corporation is an insult to their memory.

Peter Hannifan, Bournemouth

It is time we stop selling public assets to private companies and using taxes to pay their shareholders’ profits. The public should own public transport not shareholders.

Raphael Andrews, London

British Rail would benefit the whole country. As the BBC and the NHS are publicly owned, so should the rail service along with lots of other state services!

Kieron Phillips, Hartlepool

As well as the high fares and fragmented network, it is the sheer inefficiency and cost of privatisation that annoys me.

David Sterratt

Let’s get some pride back.

Tom Ransom, Brighton

Simplify fares and concentrate on running reliable trains.

Sue Horne, Brighton

We want our railway back.

Raymond Crois La, Kampen

Just bring British Rail back.

Patricia Ekins, Sheffield

Speaks for itself

Mark Hyne, Liskeard

Railways were privatised so why is the government spending £50bn to build a new line only to hand it over to a private operator for the benefit of a few people?

Mark Waterer, Ashford

Privatisation has been a typical Tory scam.

Chris Smith, Nelson

Because the rail network is too important to be left to the market.

Sarah Thursfield, Oswestry