Just another competition mess handed to speculating shareholders to make money at the expense of the commuting populace. Re-nationalise. Re-investment.

John Howard, Hemel Hempstead

Bringing back British Rail is the sensible thing to do. Unfortunately this government does not do sensible.

Malcolm Young, Grimsby

BR was better than we have now, and affordable and reliable. It was fantastic. Bring back BR.

C C, Lincoln

I hope this is not a lost cause. Tories do not want public ownership and Labour did nothing under Blair and Brown, re-letting franchises instead of direct rail control.

Richard Sharp, Polegate

Spend the subsidy on routes not shareholders.

Leila Roberts, Ripon

I quite agree, a not-for-profit set-up for the railway – a proven success with the East Coast railway. Privatisation was a very hurried piece of legislation.

Richard Kemp-Salt, Brightlingsea

What a mess this enterprise has been. It needs to be sorted now.

Vivian Jenkins, Dundee

Train travel is a public service filling a human need, not a luxury. Passengers, not customers!

Owen Hubbard, Kent

We must re-nationalise rail – at the moment it is just a charity for the rich.

Graeme Booth, Orpington

BR was created because the private railways were a shambles, as they are now. A properly run service will benefit the country and the economy, rather than a greedy few.

Steven Hands, Nottingham

Things need to change. We must have the worst railway in Europe.

Owen McGreevy, Edinburgh

Nationalise Network Rail now.

Malcolm Rodger, Bath

Private it’s theirs Public it’s ours.

Paul Houldsworth, York

Ridiculous profits and raised fares. The taxpayer should own this and government should subsidise it properly. Bring back our vital infrastructure into public ownership.

Anya-Nicola Darr, Exeter

End the charade of buck-passing and excessive fares.

Chris Gilchrist, Bristol

Profiteering, money before service, disgraceful lies and deceit. It’s time for a change. Escape Tory and Labour lies.

Terry McKeown, Leeds

This is long overdue. Even the Conservatives in many quarters agree that nationalisation is now the only way forward. Let’s get it back in public ownership and fix it.

Jamie Bolam Scott, Nottingham

Buying tickets is fragmented and complicated.

Leslie Glass, Haverhill

There are few jobs in my home town which is only one hour from London by rail. However, few can take up jobs in London because of the exorbitant rail fares.

Jude Davies, Grantham

Bring back British Rail, run by the people for the people at a profit for the people not private business.

Derek Wagstaff, Plymouth

This must happen.

Neil Brand, London

Aspiration for passengers has deteriorated through privatisation and costs have risen. It’s a failure.

Anthony Hinds, Harrogate

I am sick of these massive corporations who charge a fortune and can’t even provide a half decent service.

James Lewis, Barnsley

The franchise system isn’t working. We need proper trains with enough coaches so that people can travel in comfort and at reasonable prices.

John Robinson, Lincoln

If private enterprise can/will not run Railtrack/Network Rail, why should it operate the profit-making parts and hold fare-payers to ransom for an essential service?

Richard Gillanders, London

Rail travel should be affordable for ordinary people. No more over-inflation price hikes.

Chirag Batavia, London

Should never have been sold off by the robbing Tories.

Derek McCarthy, Inverness

There is no argument against nationalisation.

Ken Cole, Norwich

I come from Blackpool to Manchester each day for work. This costs £3236 per year. The trains are old, dirty and generally not up to standard with the amount I am paying.

Debbie Horn, Blackpool