Get more commercial transport back on the rails and off our roads.

David Fox, Chesterfield

South East Trains is the most terribly formed transport company I have seen.

Jareth Turner, Margate

Listen to the public. This has gone on for long enough.

Andy Moore, Penzance

Nationalise all privatised industries.

John Dunn, Chesterfield

If something does not work out in a big way we seem too timid to correct the mistake (e.g. rail privatisation). Prices compare terribly to those in mainland Europe.

David Priest, Norwich

This needs to happen. What is the use of a train that is less than half-filled to capacity when you charge through the nose? Give British Rail back to the people.

Chris Yates, Northwich

Our railways would be much better suited in the public’s hands and not Cameron’s Spiv capitalists.

Gary Clark, Sunderland

A transport system is essential for our society, not for investors to make a profit. No-one should make profit on something which is a key to how we exist.

Helle Kristjansen, London

Profit over service equals major problems – hours and hours and hours of wasted time, lateness for work impacting on productivity etc. Bring back British Rail.

Ian Massey, Manchester

No to HS2. Yes to a decent Liverpool-Leeds line.

Phil Mason, Manchester

As an ex BR employee and First employee I think the railways should never have been privatised. They cost far less to run when they were BR.

Mike Devane, St Neots

It is not the fault of the workers, it is the government’s failure.

Dan Cooper, Brighton

Instead of wasting money on high speed rail, spend it on putting back all the branch lines to bring life back into the country, also creating lots more jobs.

Terry Thomson, Swansea

Railways should be a social service, not a money making one. Profit making has benefit in some limited situations. It is not a one-size-fits-all miracle cure.

Roger Sternad, Doncaster

I love travelling by train but hate lining the pockets of fat cats. We want cheap, efficient travel for all with no need for handouts to shareholders. We all own this.

Julie Ward, Bishop Auckland

East Coast Rail shows how it can be done.

Ian Ferguson, London

They should never have been de-nationalised in the first place.

Alison Damant, Bradford

Privatisation has just allowed private companies to enrich themselves at our expense.

Lawrence Paulson, Cambridge

Cross Country Trains are a disgrace. The country urgently needs new rolling stock, even countries like Georgia can buy sparkly spacious Swiss trains.

Lynne Jackson, Hinckley

Rail essential service is best and effective in public ownership.

John Marshall, Morpeth

You are doing a fantastic job.

Christine Cudworth, Wakefield

The whole rail system is a mess. Bring back British Rail.

Peter Worth, Nottingham

I am increasingly of the opinion that natural monopolies should be in public ownership.

Richard Stephenson Winter, Morpeth

A nationalised railway is run for people. All profit should be ploughed back into improving the service.

Joan George, Beaconsfield

Something like this needs to be under one umbrella to make sure things run smoothly and be sure that maintenance is properly carried out on a regular basis.

Judy Pemberton, Prestatyn

Rail privatisation has been the best argument for state ownership in the last 30 years.

John Rennie, Chepstow

East Coast is a good service and is profitable in public ownership. Keep it that way.

Christopher Shaw, Berwick-upon-Tweed

The best rail service at the moment is East Coast. Cheerful, efficient service, usually on time, makes a healthy profit. De-privatise the rest but keep the efficiencies.

Lynn Dorling, Edingley, Newark

I couldn’t take a job with a £7K pay rise because I would have had to travel to London two days a week, which made me £200 a month worse off even after the pay rise.

Gavin Hudson, Sheffield