Privatisation has only allowed for the highest rail fares in Europe, very limited competition on an infrastructure still paid for by the taxpayer. Value for money?

Gareth Valentine-Saunders, Ripon

Like water, gas and electricity, they should not have been privatised.

Nicholas Holford, Langham, Oakham

We need a unified, affordable, clean, efficient rail network that works for everyone.

Audrey Pool, Maryport

Big delays at least 2 or 3 times a week not acceptable.

Thomas Murphy, South Woodham Ferrers

Competition has just served to raise profits whilst ignoring service and lower standards for commuters. Bring control back to the people.

Jamie Osborne, Huntingdon

We are being put to shame by other countries’ rail networks. What happened to the great British Railways? Bring them Back!

Lesley Parkhouse, Bath

Bring the railways back into the fold and stop the profiteering.

Derek Lilley, Hemel Hempstead

East Coast is the best service presently in the UK, doesn’t have to pay a dividend to rich shareholders, and is less of a burden on taxpayers than any private company.

Christopher Rowe, Durham

Profits should be re-invested not go into an individual’s pocket.

Martin Ashdown, Ballater

Thatcher’s legacy is destroying the little that’s left of public Britain.

Tony Acton, London

British Rail for the people. End privatisation and stop ripping of the British public.

Colin Herrick, Lincoln

Trains are for the rich only now. They’ve priced me into car journeys only as it’s cheaper.

Darrell Hart, Croydon

Railways are simply not a service that can be run for private profit. There’s only one line there, so competition isn’t a natural feature.

Amy Leach, Leeds

Economic and reliable rail travel is not a luxury but a requirement for a modern, successful economy. Get rid of the franchises and nationalise the railways.

Ray Laidlaw, North Shields

We know that rail networks overseas in Japan, Germany and France etc., are pinnacles of public transport excellence. We need to copy them.

Geoff Brewer, Devizes

The neoliberal experiment has failed. Can we restore fairness now?

James Waite, Malton

We are all totally sick of being ripped off and feel that the only way forward is to re-nationalise the rail network.

Nounette Noble, Bradford

When returning from mainland Europe by train, I am always embarrassed by the contrast, the high prices and tattiness of our un-nationalised railways compared to the SNCF.

Sue Stewart, Newcastle-upon-Tyne

British taxpayers and rail customers pay for rail services – but don’t get the service they need – and private companies and shareholders take the profits. It’s mad.

Sally Millar, Edinburgh

Into public ownership

Col Walmsley, Newcastle-upon-Tyne

It will be fairer and safer and profit will go back into improving rail services and not to shareholders.

Robert Hart, Newcastle-upon-Tyne

The trains run late and there is no accountability, hence the prices are outrageous. If railways were re-nationalised, we could have accountability back.

Sheila Reilly, Coventry

It makes sense unlike a certain political party.

David Clarke, Nottingham

Bring back British rail

Phillip Dunkirk, Harrogate

The awful privatised railways are ours. Please give them back to us.

David White, Hull

Public transport should be what it says, not a feeder mechanism for shareholders’ pockets.

Peter Lawson, Tunbridge Wells

Get this right and more people will use the trains. Lower ticket prices and better trains. No shareholders, just us as the owners.

Laurence Dowell, Corby

Bring back British Rail and make Britain’s railways something to be proud of.

Jeff Coombs, Bournemouth

Taxpayer money built the rails and now we’re just getting ripped off by the companies that own the concessions.

Marc Brammer, Glasgow

Good idea. Good luck. Nationalisation next.

Margaret Evans, Sheffield