How can you run a railway and claim maximum customer service when you are also giving millions of pounds to shareholders who contribute nothing?

Ian Hayward, Basingstoke

21st century and our transport system is a shambles. There’s a lesson here – if it ain’t broke don’t fix it. Definitely don’t sell it.

Victoria Maclean, Telford

Why should private rail operators who make huge profits and rip us off with high fares receive much higher subsidies than British Rail did? It’s daylight robbery.

Sue Caro, London

Better for Britain. Nationalise all utilities.

Jon Brown, Morecambe

British Rail was better run than all the private rail companies put together. I should know – I have been travelling on them for more than 60 years.

Alan Spicer, Bodmin

I’m sick of 20 years of being ripped-off for lousy services.

Deborah Ryan, London

Railway workers and users together to fight for our interests.

Steve Revins, Birmingham

BR had such a poor reputation as a brand I am not surer we want it back, but we certainly don’t want the current system.

Allan Hall, York

British rail should never have been privatised, especially for profit I say re-nationalise the service.

Carole Frost, Birtley

At nearly 60 I well remember British Railways, that most small towns and villages had a rail link and most people used the train to travel.

Becky Chamberlain, Peterhead

Give us our railways back.

Jean Meek, Nottingham

If we are to support communities and re-connect to a more social way of being other than through Facebook, the rail network requires a solid base to support this from.

Alastair Stewart, Lancaster

We privatise to make money for the private sector. Why? We are not the private sector, we are Britain and we should run our services for us, not for private companies.

Matthew Mountain, London

Appalling quality and ludicrous prices of rail in the UK are uneconomical, unfair, and do nothing but push commuters to use cars. Nationalisation is for the common good.

Charlie Furness, Cardiff

Re-integrate each franchise as it expires, starting with the well-run East Coast line.

John Watson, Brighton

Everyone realises privatisation was a mistake. They just need to nudge back to British Rail.

Jane Wallace, Norwich

There are too many outside contractors. It’s a real mess and needs sorting out.

Richard Lee, Liverpool

British Rail just before privatisation was one of the most efficient railway operators in Europe.

Ann Knowles, Aberystwyth

People should not be fleeced for needing public transport to get to work. How can the rail operators defend their extortionate price rises when services are getting worse?

David Hughes, Pontefract

British Rail was cheaper and more efficient.

Tony Fielding-Raby, Lincoln

I don’t use trains, but my family does.

Henry Nayler, Watford

I could be proud again of our trains (as I am of the NHS) if only privatisation could be ended and we returned to a culture of public service to and for the public.

Colin Young, Sevenoaks

Can another government – Spain, France, Switzerland or Germany – run it next time and they have a better track record.

Lorenzo

The privatisation of British Rail has proved to be a huge mistake. Can we please learn from this one and re-nationalise it.

Margaret Tibble, London

Privatisation’s been a disaster in terms of the costs of achieving improvements to the railway.

Alastair Baily

I have never supported the privatisation of rail services in the UK and I never will.

Wendy Berentsen, Wallsend

Keep East Coast mainline nationalised – it’s the best railway in the country.

Andrew Walker, York

Railways for progress not private profit. One government-owned company for cheap fares and efficiency.

Gillian Harris, Lancing