Please, for the sake of everyone bring back British Rail.

Malcolm Cobden, Worthing

The sham promise of efficiency has been exposed as just another way of profiting from public subsidy. The system is chaotic and unfair, and should be fixed properly.

Frances Farrer, Oxford

Bring it back. It works for the people.

Mary T Johnston, Edinburgh

Privatisation has failed, tax payers pay more subsidies to give private companies more profit.

David Sherwood, Northwich

Service.

P Stone, London

Greedy, inefficient and monopolistic. That’s the reality of UK rail companies. Enough is enough. We want regulation and a state investment in our transport.

Amy Smith, Dartford

East Coast is doing an excellent job. If it is not broke do not fix it.

Colin Austin, Peterlee

A unified passenger network would be easier for passengers to understand than the current variety of levels of service, styles of timetables and trains.

David Sterratt

The railways should be run as a public good, for public benefit, not for profit to shareholders.

Craig Thomas, Manchester

Bring back British Rail.

Jack Scott, Swanage

I’m sick to death of Tory-inspired rip-offs.

Mazhar Asghar, Leeds

Since privatisation the railways have gone from bad to worse. They are now run as a profit-maker for investors rather than as a public service.

Paul Ratcliffe, Sheffield

And while you’re at it, please bring back trains with windows you can open, not air-con, so we can really enjoy the journeys breathing fresh air.

Ben Hooke, Norwich

Get rid of the layers of parasites.

Tony Nicholson, Southampton

If East coast can do it with such great service then bring it on.

Robin Richardson, Walton-on-Thames

In an ideal world we would have an integrated transport system. Simple, straightforward and easy to reach your destination.

Brian Racher

For people not profit.

Frank McQuaid, Easterhouse

The sooner the better.

David Phillips, Eastbourne

I’m sick and tired of dealing with a private monopoly. Either diversify carriers or bring back British Rail.

Mary Leneis, Abingdon

Our services belong in public hands. No more private railways or bus services.

Ian Beasley, Stoke-on-Trent

I can’t believe that only the Green Party supported re-nationalisation. Why won’t Labour?

Dominic Martin, Lechlade

Although I like the different companies and versatility in trains, private companies vary way too much in quality of service from one another and everything is confusing.

Jahmin Balde, Ipswich & Lowestoft

I saw it on the back cover of Private Eye and it represents the sentiment I have held for a long time.

Gil Southwood, London

The rail system is clearly a natural monopoly. Why are its profits going to private companies, not the British people?

Ben Bebbington, Sandwell

The rail service is one of Britain’s great national treasures. Please preserve it for future generations.

Marilyn J Wilson-Baker, Langar, Nottinghamshire

Those of us old enough remember that things were far from perfect in the era of British Rail. However, things were simpler in those days without all these franchises.

Jonathan Coombe, Tenbury Wells

I’m fed up with cancelled trains.

Anita O’Mahoney-Hamilton, Henlow

Privatisation doesn’t work. This fiasco is all the proof we need.

Michelle Hornsey, Leeds

Bring our railways back into public ownership so that the passengers (not customers) can have a decent, value-for-money service instead of being exploited by private profit.

Paul Harrop, Watton-at-Stone, Herts