Only public service can deliver a service with the public not shareholders in mind.

Martin Cummins, Edinburgh

The current rail system is an expensive shambles, rip-off for hapless passengers and an embarrassment to all.

J Mark McCoy, London

I left BR in 1995 after 18 years service, as I could see bad things happening because the changes that were made after privatisation (Potters Bar, Hatfield.)

Paul Gardener, Wallasey

The state of the current national network is a disgrace. Nationalisation of the railway system would lead to a better regulated system with lower costs for the commuter.

Theo Williams, Ryde

I have read ‘Broken Rails’ by Christian Wolmar and I concur.

Frank Sturm, Bergen Op Zoom, Netherlands

Enough is enough. The current situation needs to change.

Gregor Thomson

Bring back British Rail.

Stan Hesketh, Wigan

They should never have been privatised. The railway has been in decline ever since.

Dave Huxham, Leeds

Stop wasting tax payer money on private rail. Bring back public owned transportation.

Naomi Wallace, Otterburn

Privatisation of the rail networks does not work – I travelled to and from London from Liverpool or Carlisle for a while. Profiteering on infrastructure is damaging.

Carl Dodd, Birkenhead

I’m an ex-Saltley guard. This infrastructure that’s losing a battle is ludicrous. Bring back British Rail.

Tony Sandland, Birmingham

Privatisation hasn’t worked for many franchisees and definitely hasn’t worked for the passenger. Bring back BR. DB was 100% cheap and punctual when I worked in Germany.

Colin Wane, Barnsley

Transport should always be in public hands.

John McGregor, Blyth

For the people, not profits for the few.

Veronica Harris, London

Even my father, with very right-wing sympathies, and who worked for BR, thought the privatisation was stupid.

Susan Tideswell, Newcastle-upon-Tyne.

None of the essential public services should ever have been privatised, transport especially. The backbone of a working successful Britain, strong and globally competitive.

Bob Pearson, Chelmsford

I’m a frequent user of the line to London. It’s excellent. No need to change. Also, it’s safer to have the national infrastructure owned by the nation, not by global capital.

Christine Hartas, Newcastle-upon-Tyne

I loved British Rail. Bring it back now.

Chris Lovett, Charlwood, Surrey

Public transportation should be nationalised.

Denise Scott, Newcastle-upon-Tyne

We need an integrated, nationally owned rail service, not one fractured into competing companies – some partly owned by other countries’ national rail companies.

Sheila Cross, Northallerton

Privatisation doesn’t work for the public, only for the shareholders. Let’s get it back working for the public.

Kenneth Muschamp, Retford

You know it makes sense.

Sheila Sheppard, Milton Keynes

Short-sighted dogma caused the chaos.

Alan Perkins, Canterbury

Yes, I quite agree, privatisation is a dirty word.

Jean O’Donnell, Bury

I’m sick of paying ridiculously high fares and having to tolerate consistently poor service.

Justin Cole, Warwick

It’s the only sensible option to run a network.

Andy Kuss, Bath

I lived in SE London for a long and happy time and used BR quite a lot on the way into town. Never was I late or felt unsafe. Privatising is a huge mistake. British Rail forever.

Ant

You must drastically improve all public transport. British Railways should be amongst the best in the world.

Richard Hunter, Pontefract

Commendable objective.

Anthony Oliver, Leeds