I am not a regular user of UK trains but there can be no doubt that in terms of price, cleanliness and punctuality, things are much worse than before privatisation.

Jonathan Fox, Espinho, Portugal

Railways should be run for the good of the people and not exist to line shareholders’ pockets.

Norman Horton, Darlington

A long-time commuter in my youth, now living where there is no rail service – but strongly believe rail network should all be in public ownership.

Lynda Lorenzo, Sutton-on-Sea

Boot Arriva out ASAP!

Thomas Coyle

The current railway system does not offer effective competition or serve its customers well, while funds are creamed off for private profit.

Alan Boyland, Southam

Why when it is making money for the downtrodden taxpayer do they want to turn it over to losers?

Helen Herridge, Conwy

Standard text book economics tells you that private ownership of a natural monopoly is a bad idea. Train service is cheaper and better in countries with public ownership.

Thomas Renstrom, Durham

And the rest of the utilities.

Philip Quaife

British Rail can operate efficiently and as a profitable business under public ownership, for the benefit of the nation. It just needs the right people in charge.

Nigel Holmes, Hull

We used to live in Staffordshire and hope to return to UK next year. We’re appalled at what Tory doctrinaire policies have done to UK railways.

John Porter, France

Profit motive built the railways, when they really competed with one another. Now, and especially after WWII, it is a national asset. It must stay.

Andrew Hoadley, Archway

As a young person who never experienced British Rail, I see it as a really positive thing for the country and would love to see it’s reestablishment.

Aaron o’Sullivan, Glenarm

The new timetable does not work.

Dexter Dennis, Chalkwall

Let the devil of the Thatcher years now and for always be behind us and let us learn from those with the technology of today so by this we all benefit.

Anthony Wayne Simpson, Cardiff

Transport is a key piece of national infrastructure. It has no business being run for profit in the private sector.

Stuart Bishop, Manchester

I despair when we have sold off our national assets, from rail to energy to water to money. Bring back British Rail and leave the Post Office alone.

Alistair Ligertwood, Liverpool

Let the franchises run to their end and then take them back without the need for compensation.

Michael Kirkman, York

Unacceptable service at continually greater unacceptable prices. Please bring back British Rail.

Vikesh Mistry, London

Should never have been privatised in the first place. Railways are a national asset for the people.

Robert Thornton, Brighton.

Southwestern Trains are the bane of my life.

Philip Hubbard, Southampton

Privatisation is a mess. It’s just ripping off the public and taxpayers.

Christine Sweeney, Durham

I’m a past British Railways’ employee on Sealink.

Graham Robinson, Faversham

Let’s get back all that has been privatised to make the rich richer.

Wayne Cargill, London

This will be the deciding factor of my vote in the next general election.

Joe Romero, Billericay

It makes it very difficult to work in London whilst living in Leicester when train season tickets are so expensive.

Sundeep Maini, Leicester

I support you fully against this greed and want the link broken between private corporations and ministerial back-scratching.

James

I cannot believe that it is appropriate for German and French nationalised rail companies to run British Rail, while our own success stories, like East Coast Trains, cannot.

Eddie Kelly, Peterborough

For people not for profit.

Owen Smithson, Hornsea

First Capital Connect London to Brighton service is dreadful. Old trains, noisy, rattley, uncomfortable, freezing cold or baking hot. It’s a complete rip off.

Jim Allen, Brighton

I totally agree with your proposal – nothing else to say – we all know it makes sense.

Ralph Holden, London