We must keep this. Profit versus service and shareholder dividend always means we lose out.

Colin Waugh, Stockton-on-Tees

The train operating companies are fleecing taxpayers and the government.

Una-Jane Winfield, London

Fair price for fares. No stockbroker style ticket buying. Stick to advertised prices, no unannounced hourly changes to ruin student travel budgeting.

Jane Skyrme, Hereford

For the people, not profits for the few.

Veronica Harris, London

The trains are old, dirty and late or cancelled.

Lesley Ward, Manchester

Put safety and people first, not profit.

Ann Lovell, Swindon

It is time all this privatisation stopped. There should be institutions looked after by a civil service.

Pat Ingram, Exeter

There should be investment in longer platforms and trains so that each ticket sold also has a seat. Also commuter only trains during rush hours so nobody has to stand.

Richard Barraball, Brighton

Re-nationalising the railways is the only rational solution.

Gill Cookson, Sennen Cove

We need a fairly priced service with enough carriages to make sure there is less over-crowding and that any profit is re-invested in the service, not to shareholders.

Trevor Green, Worcester

This has to be done. No more big profits from robbing the people who pay Fares.

Peter Forster, Haltwhistle

How long will it take the government to stop these vultures giving the public an awful service?

Andy Welling, Bristol

Only a unified service can provide what we need. The current state of the railways is madness. More use of freight trains can free up our roads and cut costs too.

Aj Cross, London

All utilities should be run by the state for the benefit of the people not shareholders.

Malcolm Ashton, Newcastle-upon-Tyne.

I’m sickened of being ripped off by shareholders, tax-dodging corrupt companies, and getting very poor customer service in return. Audit of the whole organisation now.

Ann Madine, Sandy

The Tories won’t do it but why didn’t Labour?

Roger Wells, Stourbridge

Give us back our rail system.

Susan Giles, Tynemouth

If it improves service then I’m happy.

Michael Greenwood, Braintree

If it ain’t broke don’t fix it (according to your political views). Leave alone and away from the clutches of your financial cronies. It’s ours not yours.

Peter Whiteman, Chelmsford

Go Ellie Harrison!

Sabina Stefanova, London

Southwest Trains are horrible.

Timi Horwell, London

This country is too small and we must have British Rail.

Ray Freeman, Bradford

National infrastructure, like railways, with no competitive market, deserves to be in public ownership.

David Charnley, London

A service paid for by us and we also get to vote for the government to manage our rail service.

William McGiven, Derby

This is a no-brainer. Profit has become a very dirty word. Basic services, i.e. our infrastructure, should belong to all for the good of all.

Irene Rhodes, Wakefield

Nationalisation is what the rail system needs.

Isaac Reid-Guest, Birmingham

Total support for this. I use the Northeast line a lot. Private sectors failed but it turns a good profit for the taxpayer now that government runs it.

Mike Weaver, Newcastle-upon-Tyne

Power to the people.

Brett Langsdale, Nottingham

I am a former employee of British Rail and a regular traveller. The current West Coast is a shambles.

Robert Judson, Windermere

I’m tired of monopolists extorting from me over an essential service.

Nicholas Simcik Arese, Oxford