We need to bring back British Rail on a “not for profit” basis in order that we have a safe and prompt railway in the UK.

Bill Allen, Manchester

It’s about time we gave power over train prices back to the people and took the initiative to have more state-owned commodities.

Tim Shields, Chorley

The East Coast line has demonstrated how a well run line can satisfy its customers and put its profits into the Exchequer. What more do you want?

Konnie Lloyd, Nottingham

If we can run a service not for the profit of a few but for the good of the people then why not? The train operating companies are not genuinely competitive anyway.

Noah Law, Lostwithiel

Travelling on railways in Europe shows us up. Elsewhere, better and cheaper. Privatisation has been a massive fraud against the public

David Challis, Macclesfield

It’s time this government realised that private isn’t always better than public. It’s time to re-nationalise.

Sheila Loffill, Knaresborough

I’ve just returned from train travel through France, Italy and Switzerland and Eurostar. I then went from Paddington to Newton Abbot by First Great Western – oh dear, shameful.

John Tucker, Brixham

Privatisation has been a disaster.

John Lloyd, Exeter

Stop privatising as it doesn’t work.

Michael Johnston, Northampton

It’s time to roll any income from trains back into infrastructure and lower fares.

Christian Murray, Bognor Regis

Privatisation was a botched ideological part of roll-back the state, John Major’s attempt to go where Maggie did not. Other countries saw that it was folly and did not.

David Drew, Rickmansworth

Stop charging the taxpayers double. Not only do the public pay their fares, but then they pay the train operators’ shareholders as well, by way of subsidies.

Billie Soule, Grays

No more privatisation.

Michael Hing, London

Rail is a necessary public service and should belong to the public.

Kaotuka Raaman, Sidcup

Of course all public services should be owned by the state, i.e. us. This includes railways.

Rosemary Scott, Chester

The provision of essentials like water, power and transport should obviously not be in private hands.

Roger Higgs, Bude

Profits back into the running of the railways rather than shareholders’ pockets makes more sense than what stands at the moment.

Paul McDonnell, Morden

Poor, poor service.

Dan Rees, Swansea

Figures show that the government will be better off owning the rail network.

Keith Garr, Durham

It will be fairer and safer and profit will go back into improving rail services and not to shareholders.

Robert Hart, Newcastle-upon-Tyne

We should re-nationalise all our sold-off utilities. No-one asked us for permission.

Joyce Wood, Northampton

Nationalised public transport works well in lots of other countries.

Stephen Gidley, Haslingden

I agree with all previous comments, and we need our train network to be re-nationalised as soon as possible.

Janet Guest, Sheffield

A continued increase in price without a reciprocal increase in service and standards. This needs to change.

Liam McMillan, Brighton

I use the train and absolutely everything is geared up to people who need to work.

Debbie Edwards, London

Stop privatising our services.

Heidi Crompton, Bolton

A profitable asset for the UK not shareholders.

Rob Bowles, Manchester

The present railway system is a shambles. Re-nationalise it now.

Barry Crozier, Ipswich

Why do we have such an expensive and antiquated rail system ? Bring back British Rail.

Simon Blackmore, Manchester