After leaving school and joining British Rail it was supposed to be a career for life not just till 1998. What happened ?

Chaz Coupland, Basingstoke

Open up the closed lines and bring back the platelayers. Put railway people in a real uniform.

Paula Du Spearman, Redhill

It would be good to have rail travel available to all of us and the need for profit to be at the bottom of the priority list.

Marie Macfarlane, Glasgow

Privatisation hasn’t worked for the national good.

Michael Young, London

What a way to run a railway!

Stuart Daw, Newcastle-under-Lyme

Privatisation has been a disaster. Let the state run the railways – they did a much better job.

Barbara Webb, York

The railways were broken up and privatised for ideological reasons, resulting in a costly mess. Re-integrate now and let’s have a co-ordinated cost-effective railway.

Martin Messias, London

I have had to use a car as Southern is so unreliable for essential travel – like going to work.

Natalie Henstock, London

Privatisation does not work. The gas and electricity proves that we are all being ripped off.

James Dinsdale, Middlesbrough

More profits for public services, less to greedy shareholders.

Ann Bywater, Loughborough

Rail privatisation was a hurried, botched disaster. Costly for the UK taxpayer and has brought no real long-lasting benefit. Bring it back under our control..

Richard Edwards, Cirencester

The country and the people need British Rail back.

Eamonn Neilson, Belfast

Consistently unreliable service which is delayed, cancelled, or re-routed last minute, with over packed trains, and increasing fares. Something needs to change.

Jason Pak, Worcester Park

Privatising the national rail network was the worst possible thing that could have happened to our national transport system. Bring back public control, not big corporations.

Kieranne Page, London

We need a rail service, not unethical profiteering at public expense.

Alex Kay, London

About time too.

Roy Eyley, Farnsfield

The rail network has become a cash cow for multi-national corporations. Any profits should be spent on improving the infrastructure.

Roy Davis, Caerphilly

Get this right and more people will use the trains. Lower ticket prices and better trains. No shareholders, just us as the owners.

Laurence Dowell, Corby

BR was owned by the taxpayer. When it was privatised, any interest some taxpayers had was taken away, although they are still contributing to the rail system.

Maggie Good, Ipswich

Bring back national rail and the consistency it would bring.

Simon Mercer, Maidstone

Railways are an essential environmental way of travelling around the country, and the government should be encouraging rail travel. Re-nationalisation is the only way.

Kristina Taylor, Cardiff

Bring back people over profit.

Saul Blake, Cambridge

Public funding for the railways should be for public ownership, not for private companies.

Susan Cason, Dronfield

The money wasted on all the companies involved in running the railways. All have a chairman and a board of directors etc.

Alan Newstead, Eastleigh

Start with the East Coast line and take the others up as the current contracts end.

Mic Porter, Whitley Bay

Bring back British Rail.

Ashley Sinani, London

East Coast in public hands has given big profits to the government. We should not be giving all the profits to those who are already superrich.

Cora Lowe, Stockton-on-Tees

Please bring back British Rail.

Julian Bebb, Taunton

I generally moan the loss of our National Railway owned and run by us and not the French or German franchises. Lets pay the right price for travel not subsidising others.

Edward Cordell, Newark-on-Trent