Why not carry out a poll of the East Coast line commuters. Their view should be fairly conclusive.

Jack Butterworth, Harrogate

Privatisation only benefits a few and British Rail should be run for the many.

Paul Wardle, Derby

It’s really important that we get a rail service run for people and not for private profit, clean, efficient and affordable.

Nick Monaghan, Castleford

Let’s take back our railways out of the hands of the French and German governments and Branson of the Virgin Islands.

Norman Partington, Warrington

I am a Londoner, and one of the reasons why I left for the South Coast was because of the disgrace that is public transport. I support re-nationalisation fully.

Michael Apostolou, Worthing

Railways in countries many times the size of Britain, considered to be ‘developing’, are unified and run primarily to serve the public, People before profit, please.

Wilson Smeaton, Wooler

David Cameron was at Bedford station before he was P.M. I asked him if he would re-nationalise the railways and he categorically said no and signed my book the same.

Francis Heyes, Newark

It is insane that we have a system of legalised highway robbery, where we pay more now to private firms for them to make a profit.

Mark Leith, Manchester

Bring our services back to public ownership.

Brenda Grunwell, Ipswich

Hopefully we will have a nationalised railway company in an independent Scotland.

Catherine Wilson, Campbeltown

The rail fare-structure alone is madness, plus I’m a passenger, not some customer to be ripped off.

Richard Paul, Stroud

No more taxpayers’ money for private rail contractors. Cancel all private franchises and re-nationalise the whole railway network under the British Rail banner.

Ged Travers, Coventry

Bring back value for money and a reliable service of yesterday and stop the profit making short cuts of today.

Brian White, Doncaster

Not even Thatcher was crazy enough to privatise the railways.

Stella Hawkins, Hounslow

Re-nationalise the current rail system.

Jonathan Goode, Caterham

There is no need for the profit motive in the rail industry, but a socially-owned network cannot return to the pre-90s. We can learn from the privatisation experiment.

Stephen Smith, Hawick

Fares are too expensive under private control. Improve the service by investing money into the network directly and not into scandalous salaries and bonuses.

Pedro Pereira, Milton Keynes

The franchise system allows excess profits to be made at the expense of the taxpayer and the traveller.

Ian Jenkins

If BR had been given the subsidies that are being given to private companies we could have had the best railway in the World.

Arthur Crawford, Edinburgh

How hard is it to book a bike onto a train? Bring back ‘guard carriages’.

Steve Roach, Worcester

Because this just isn’t working.

Lauren Hellicar, Brighton

Bring back British Rail. The way things are run now is shambolic. Why do we have to put up with high fares and companies who simply run trains as a hobby?

David Taylor, Barry

The railway system of this country is too important to be left to private companies to run. We want more public accountability for rail services and pricing.

Susan Roberts, Nottingham

It’s the only way you will ever get an efficient rail system.

Barrie Hood, Newton Aycliffe

This could spur the economy’s growth with super fast trains.

Alistair Ewing, London

I think that a country’s public transport is a reflection of what the powers that be think of their citizenry.

Stephen Newberry, Hove

People before profit’ says it all. Rail network is crucial for the nation on so many different levels. We can’t leave it up to companies whose only concern is the bottom line.

Sarah Dewing, Epsom

Fares are too high. The system needs to be run for the public.

Alex Shearman, Solihull

Railways should be run for the public as a service and not for mega profits for the rich.

Anthony Kelly, Derby

And whilst we are about it, bring back steam.

Sue Cavendish, London