With private rail companies one of the main considerations is profit and keeping shareholders happy. Bring back British Rail – a public service that serves the public.

Antonia Martinez, Stockton-on-Tees

I’m an ex railway employee, when it was British Rail until Beeching had his way.

Kenneth Johnson, Alnwick

Bring back British Rail and stop the Tory destruction of the country’s infrastructure.

Anthony Hill, Crewe

Modelled on the East Coast service.

Blair Breton, Southsea

Bring back British Rail.

Marsh Stephens, Hull

Selling off the assets of British Rail was legalised theft.

Brian Boulton, Bradford

After twenty years of greed, incompetence and lack of investment, it is time to accept that private capital cannot run a railway or a health service.

Edward Sherlock, Carmarthen

The Tories are disgracefully making worse what they started in the early 90s to benefit their rich friends.

Simon Newell, London

The railway is a public method of transport, fascination and convenience. I believe private companies should have no say in how our railways are run.

Jack Sayers Shaw, Bournemouth

Our country should be united by one, fair rail system, run in the interest of the country and not for profit.

Joe Wood, London

Privatisation has meant soaring ticket prices, ever larger subsidies and inferior service. Transport in the hands of the state (East Coast) will always outperform private.

Peter Sansom, Glasgow

British Rail I miss you!

Ian Crockford, Birmingham

The money we pay for train travel would be better spent by a nationalised rail service. I’m sick of paying for fourth rate service.

Brian Bentley, Bath

As a student in the sixties I could travel from London to Brighton for a pound and. on occasions for an extra shilling (5p), travel on the famous Brighton Belle In luxury.

Christine Skinner, London

My late father worked for BR and Rail Track and always moaned about how bad things had got after the take over, about penny-pinching mend-and-make-do and poor management.

Leslie Holder, Reading

The privatised railways are a total mess. Re-nationalise and run them as a public service, like, say, the roads.

Hywel Phillips, Reading

It would be nice to get a service that worked. Train travel is brilliant. When you pay for a seat you should get one. It should be run for people not profit.

Kate Doyle, Cambridge

Bring back British Rail. It belongs to us, the public.

Karen Maloney, Maidstone

Shameful actions by respective governments have badly served the population as a whole. Labour need to get back to principles and act, before it’s too late. Some chance.

Paddy Costall, London

None of the essential public services should ever have been privatised, transport especially. The backbone of a working successful Britain, strong and globally competitive.

Bob Pearson, Chelmsford

Almost every country in Europe has state-run railways, all of which are better than ours. I know because I have used them extensively.

Steve O’Donnell, Lancaster

For too long the profits of these private companies have been fed back into the pockets of shareholders at the expense of the British public.

Richard Norris, Hull

What is wrong with a service? Why does everything have to provide a profit to shareholders?

Mark Bishop, York

We have a ridiculously fragmented and expensive rail system. It is time it was taken back into public ownership.

Malcolm Davison, Gateshead

It is ludicrous that we have to pay for an over-expensive, inefficient railway system because of the political dogma of politicians.

Brian Mitchell, London

This is our railway. It should be run as a service and not profit going into private hands.

Jessica Gale, Nottingham

Beeching made the railways fail. To rebuild their strength bring back British Rail.

Danfox Davies, Bournemouth

Railways not for private profit.

Stephen Cullen, Prescot

A railway for people, not profit.

Marc Harris, Blackpool