All essential services should be nationalised. That’s rail, water, energy, post office, and schools under local authority control.

Sylvia Coles, Nottingham

The first mistake was the Beeching axe. This destroyed the infrastructure which made the re-routing of trains relatively simple.

Alan Carson, Prudhoe

I’m sick of paying ridiculously high fares and having to tolerate consistently poor service.

Justin Cole, Warwick

Privatisation may be cheaper short tern, but if the railways were publicly-owned any future profits would benefit the country not shareholders.

Barbara Brogan, Letchworth

The lack of communication between private network operators has left train journeys devoid of the human touch that it once had as British Rail.

Lucy Caithness, London

I’d like to see the railway in public ownership again – in Germany as well as in the UK.

Marko Lauten, H

East Coast line has proved that a state-run railway can succeed and make money, so let’s keep it nationalised and extend railway nationalisation.

Margaret Hunt, Doncaster

Transport to benefit the country should be run for public benefit, not profit. A unified system makes sense.

Moira Garland, Leeds

Nothing but delays and strikes on Southern. But fares still keep rising. Privatisation is not helping passengers.

Tom Faulkner, Eastbourne

Privatising the rail network is the stupidest Idea ever lobbied for by money-grabbing racketeers.

Carl Clifton, Nottingham

Privatise it now. Let’s get back to being a real railway again.

Ian Gornall, Preston

The privatised railways are vastly expensive money-pumps from the public purse.

Robert Cockcroft, Ashford, Kent

Northern Rail – what a rip off.

Anthony Webster, Newcastle-upon-Tyne

Railway privatisation is ‘Poll Tax on Wheels’, always has been and always will be. Why are we subsidising it continuously when we could just take it back?

Julie Goodman, London

Rail fares are too expensive. Trains don’t run on time. It’s overdue for a change.

Kathleen Russell, Wetherby

The Northern Rail franchise is a bad joke.

Robert Ibbotson, Sheffield

Please make our railway one again. Ever since the fragmentation passengers have become secondary to profits. I think safety issues will be a higher priority then.

Josie Wassall, Birmingham

No competition, no investment, still being subsidised with taxpayers’ money going into private hands and outrageous fare rises.

Leon Salter

The idea of rail travel was to enable lots of people to travel cheaply, comfortably, safely, and on time. It was for people, not profit. That should still be the aim.

William Markham, Darlington

Re-nationalise now.

Richard King, Bristol

Nothing taken out of public ownership is an improvement. All they are interested in are profits for shareholders. The only losers are the consumers.

John McIntosh, Thornhill

Apart from the massive debt, fares have risen out of all proportion and they are still getting funding from the public purse. Shareholders win and taxpayers lose.

Leslie Scaife, Southport

I grew up in rural Kent in the 80’s and became a commuter to Central London. The trains were old but the service under BR was reliable- Now is a disgrace.

Lee Featherstone, Croydon

Rail transport is a mess in this country.

John Heath, Scunthorpe

Take our now totally fragmented national railway out of the hands of the privateers who are exploiting it to the full. Only re-nationalisation will make it work again.

Stephen Riggott, Southampton

A railway system for the public and owned by the public.

Simon Kirkham, High Wycombe

I spoke to a man outside the train station on the subject matter and was quite intrigued. I’m only 14 but it’s part of my future so I thought it was a good idea to sign up.

Ellis Sullivan, Sheffield

A simple, unified rail system with standardised fares has got to be better than the current complicated and still-inadequate rail provision we have.

Phillipa Partington, Bedford

Down with our corporate overlords.

Joseph Kemp, Keighley

A well-run public transport system is an essential part of a sustainable society. A properly-funded, publicly owned rail system a key element, less expensive than private.

David Ashton, Hitchin