Privatisation has failed to save money for the public purse or the travelling public. All it has provided is lots of expensive liveries. We need to re-nationalise now.

Guy Amedro, Gorebridge

Isn’t it obvious?

Emma Robbins

Privatisation hasn’t worked for the travelling public. Politicians, their friends, corporate bodies, the City etc. have profited from privatisation. It’s a public service.

Robert Harper, Nottingham

Privatisation has been shown to not work. Taxpayers are paying three times what they would if the railways were nationalised. Performance is down and fares are up.

Jacqueline Rattray, London

Services don’t need to make money. They are what you spend money on.

Matt Harradine, Bristol

I am a regular rail user. East Coast line works, returning money to the exchequer not shareholders.

Sue Winterburn, York

Can we have normal fares, instead of being ripped off by private companies?

Paul Burrows, West Wickham

East Cost Rail worked, so can the rest.

Julian Boyce, Nottingham

Bring back British Rail – it is proven to be more efficient – as the East Coast route.

Claire Goodwin, Southsea

British Rail for the people. End privatisation and stop ripping of the British public.

Colin Herrick, Lincoln

Why should people who cannot afford to get on a train pay for those who also cannot afford to get on a train? If anything, our rail infrastructure should be non-profit.

Shane Ward, Leyton

People should benefit, not corporations. Privatisation gives a poorer, more expensive option. No examples of improved service/cost-effectiveness with rail privatisation.

Mike Taylor, Sheffield

Listen to the public. This has gone on for long enough.

Andy Moore, Penzance

I’m currently enduring largely inflated prices and constant improvement work which disrupts the service.

Adrian J Andrews, Worthing

Why did we privatise a profit-making national treasure in the first place? It was utter cronyism, the same as the undervalued Post Office.

Richard Waugh, Holt

What a great big mistake privatising the railway. It’s another money making opportunity.

Simon Joseph Evans, Bishop Auckland

Bring back British Rail. All is forgiven.

Andrew Green, Swansea

Privatisation – lining shareholder’s pockets since 1995.

Gail Bishop, Caterham

For too long a rich minority has controlled key parts of our society. First we will get the trains back then all our other basic utilities.

Antony Woolley

We currently have a disjointed patchwork of private interests dictating the provision of rail services in accordance with the profit motive. I want to see a collectively owned system that is affordable to all!

Jonathan Brown, London

Our train service is non-existent. Delays, cancellations, strikes.

Dhilllon Bainsford, Manchester

Considering the public already subsidises the rail network 3-4 billion a year, yet fares continue to rise. The entire rail network should be standardised to public good.

Ethan Radford, Nottingham

The UK has the most expensive and over-complex tickets in the EU.

Dean Robinson, Hastings

I could get to London from Plymouth for £14 on an InterCity Saver back in the day. Now it’s about £180. Where did it all go wrong?

Jack Mills, Plymouth

Bring back our rail service. It was a service, not a business.

Tom Daly, Edinburgh

It ain’t broke – don’t fix it.

Kitty Grove-Stephensen, Middlesbrough

Trains should be run for the people, not for private profit.

Toby Montyn, Ramsgate

The pretended benefits of privatisation have nowhere been more brutally exposed than in the chaos and wastage of resources that have afflicted the railways.

Graham Croft, London

The railways should be run for the benefit of people, not profiteering shareholders. Nothing has improved since privatisation, except their bank balances.

Christine Butler, Mansfield