As an ex-railway employee, I am totally opposed to rail privatisation. The railways belong to the public. Bring back British Rail.

Paul Knight, Australia

End the current farce of increasing fares just to line the pockets of the fat cats.

Steve Farrow, Southampton

British Railwas more publicly orientated and less just out for profit. It just makes for an awful railway system.

Justin Cryer, Weston-super-Mare

The railways should be under public ownership.

Phoebe Taylor-Thorpe, Rotherham

The railways should always have been left in public ownership and not run for private profit but in the interest of the user.

Jonathan Hayter, Redruth

Stop the complete annihilation of the guard’s role from McNullty, the government and shareholders.

Chris Davies, Eastbourne

It’s a network so it needs to be one organisation.

Gary Cook, Cullompton

Re-nationalise immediately. The service is poor and the prices disgraceful.

Charlie Deeney, Derry

British Rail, as a publicly owned company, offered an efficient, well-run service with the customer at the fore, whereas privatisation puts monetary gain first.

Diane Edmonds, Grimsby

The day of the corporation must end. A corporation has human rights now and everything is done out of greed. What was owned by the people should stay with the people.

Grande Briggs-White, Southampton

Well done. First step, save East Coast mainline.

Alan Holmes, Durham

The railways being run by private companies just doesn’t work. A unified network run for people, not profit, is the only answer.

Bob Hayden-Gilbert, Machynlleth

For passengers not profiteers!

Stuart Terry, Peterborough

Privatisation has been an expensive lie. I want services brought back under public ownership.

Tom Dussek, Brighton

If the railways are a loss-making industry, why are there big payouts to shareholders? Where does that money come from?

Frank Belsey, Enfield

The British Railways Board ran an excellent train service. These private companies are useless, typical Tory crap. So bring back British Rail.

Colin Flowerday, Holt

And restore the lines that Beeching should never have axed.

Robert Harvey, Bourne

Some things in life should never be privatised. Education, the NHS, the Police, the Post Office and the Railways.

Bobbie Syrett, Leeds

It’s nonsense for fragmentation in so small a landmass. We all prefer train travel in a single network.

Andree Rodriguez-Veglio, Daventry

Bring back British Rail.

Craig Gardiner, London

Nowadays I don’t even bother looking for a seat going to and from Paddington as there are never any. It is so not worth £50+ to be sat in a doorway for two hours.

David Briggs, Westcliff-on-Sea

It’s time all public services returned to being just that, not private profit-making enterprises.

Sarah Patton, Haslemere

None of these people who own the railways know what they’re doing, so limit the damage and give it back to those who might know.

William Hp, London

If East Coast can run efficiently and effectively then so should the whole network without ‘middle people’ – including shareholders – taking the profit out of it all.

Christine Hood, St Albans

It should be run not for profit but for the best and cheapest service.

Ian Casey, London

British Rail for all.

Stephen Chalk, Southampton

It cannot be right when trains are more expensive that using a car. Train travel should benefit all the people, not just to make profits for the few.

David Finch, Luton

Railways aren’t a market. If I don’t like, say, the London to Bristol train, I can’t choose a different train company. Capitalism without competition is just profiteering.

Tom Morris

How can you run a railway and claim maximum customer service when you are also giving millions of pounds to shareholders who contribute nothing?

Ian Hayward, Basingstoke

Privatisation – the worst thing in the world for what should be a national organisation.

Anne Gale, Bristol