After BR, can we do water, electricity, gas, and buses please?

Paul Grayshan, Leeds

I am from Austria and Britain needs British Rail.

Tim Rauscher, Wien

It’s time we the taxpayers have more say on how our money is spent.

Robert Gordon, Liverpool

I want the integrated functioning system we used to have, at affordable prices and employing porters, line gangs, cleaners etc. – all the jobs there used to be.

Erica Flint, Egremont

It is supposed to be public transport after all.

Donald Purdy, Wakefield

No system is perfect, but lining the pockets of big business with public money, while enjoying an expensive and inferior service, is the worst of all worlds.

Jane Ayres, New Mills

The East Coast Main Line is both clean and comfortable. The fares are competitive, the service is first class. If that was spread over other lines it would be marvellous.

Vic Hall, Balderon

This should be affordable for everyone and not just the rich.

Aaron Fry, Plymouth

No public services like this should benefit shareholders rather than users.

Karen Chambers, Edinburgh

The only way forward.

Lucy Bell, Reading

They should never have been privatised. The government conspired to make them look unprofitable at the time and also at the time of Beeching.

Allan Jones, Elgin

Trains are more environmentally friendly than planes. Cut train fares and make them more efficient by uniting the service. Bring back British Rail.

Grace Kavanagh, London

Privatisation has been a disaster for passengers and taxpayers – but very profitable for a few businesses.

Tim Bounds, Stockton

I’m sick of the ticketing system, sick of the overcrowding, most of all sick of the cavalier attitude to any complaint, or no response at all.

Irene Double, Keighley

A rail network is a natural monopoly, and one that we have no choice but to use. As such it makes sense, and justice, for it to be run for public, not private, benefit.

Jonathan Dore, Downham Market

The trains were privatised under the Tory mantra that everything not private is useless, now we have a few wealthy people getting mega rich at everyone’s expense.

Mike Friend

After spending time living in Norway where the state owns the rail system and you can travel cheaply, I am even more furious at the cost of travel in the UK on rail.

Jesamine Bartlett, Market Drayton

I fully agree, the government needs to stop creating private profit on everything. The railways are there to support the economy, not necessarily directly create the profit.

Steve O’Connell, Farnborough

About time. Let’s go for it.

Nick Green, Brighton

The national services of this country should be back in the public’s hands, fares should be agreed by the public and subsidies should not be going into corporate profits.

Clive West, Beckenham

The railways should be for people, not private profit.

Margaret Berry, Nottingham

We are sick of over-priced and over-crowded trains. Privatisation has failed to bring the improvements promised and has just resulted in fat profits for the few.

Barbara Nelson, Leeds

While you’re at it, re-nationalise gas, electricity, phones and water.

Roddy Macdonald, Sheffield

Better train transport is vital to cut emissions and pollution and improve accessibility for people outside cities. Profits should be re-invested to develop a bigger network.

Fiona Maclennan, Dunfermline

Stop siphoning public money away from public good into private hands. It’s our railway.

Carolyn Dougherty, York

The Government should be running the rail lines, not the shareholders.

Bill Murphy, York

Give us back our overpriced rail network.

Lee Roberts, Dartmouth

Nationalisation will create price stabilisation through economies of scale. BBBR.

Jamie Mckale, London

We need British Rail.

Sophie Lea Gerrard, Streatham