Standard text book economics tells you that private ownership of a natural monopoly is a bad idea. Train service is cheaper and better in countries with public ownership.

Thomas Renstrom, Durham

I support this totally.

Gary Taylor, Epsom

I love travelling by train for both ease of use and environmental reasons, but I feel bringing back BR will mean fares are less confusing and cheaper.

Richard Harcombe, Northwich

Time to put British Rail back into public ownership.

Jeremy Peace, Sheffield

I am strongly against this sell-off.

Derek Shaw, York

Things can only get better if we bring it back. Fairer fares and no complicated deals.

Robert Gordon, London

I am a free market capitalist, but privatisation only works when the consumer has choice. The consumer has no choice – they must use the rail company which runs the line.

Marcus Stead, Cardiff

it is time to take our core industries away from the thieves and fat cats and restore them to the public sector. People before profits. Off with their heads.

Dean Bell, Retford

Our publicly-owned rail system was raped by the Tories and sold off to their buddies who’ve just made a total screw-up of the whole affair.

Ian McKinnon, Newcastle-under-Lyme

I wish to see the railways re-nationalised, because it will be back as a service for the public, rather than a source of cash for the rich.

Ben Walsh, Cambridge

Why are my taxes going towards subsidising private companies? Our taxes should be spent for the benefit of us all, and not on a few fat cat exploiters.

Peter Howard, London

Undo what is the world’s greatest train robbery.

Liam Hartzenberg, Coventry

Bring back British Rail. The present set-up is a complicated mess.

Ann Milroy, London

Bringing back British Rail is the best idea in many a year!

Bob Rosenthal, Blandford

It is my opinion that the railway system (BR) was stolen from the nation by the government of the day, much the same as the Royal Mail more recently.

Mark Horseman, Billingham

Privatisation means low wages and worse terms and conditions for staff, excessive returns for management and corporations, and poorer service for the public.

Jim Shannon, Harrogate

If there is profit to be made, let it be made by and for the masses, not for a few bloated shareholders.

Jessica Barfield, York

It’s great that we finally have a forum to help put an end to this crazy state of affairs that is rail privatisation.

Stephen Millership, Stockport

Give the railways back to the people.

Ellie Rose Elliott, Whitley Bay

I remember when it was affordable to travel by train. It’s far too expensive these days, so I use my car. I’m not paying for the greedy fat cats’ huge salaries and bonuses.

Robert Collis, Chesterfield

I’m a student and the prices of trains are extortionate, especially for cramped and delayed services. I often have to travel to London for fieldwork and it’s food or work.

Alesia Harris, Woking

We need to bring the railways back into public ownership rather than giving money to private (and mostly foreign) companies.

David Black, Harrogate

All we have now is privatised regional monopolies run for the benefit of shareholders. Let’s bring back service for passengers and freight.

Hayley Griffin, Edinburgh

The railways are in desperate need of being re-nationalised as the privatisation of the railways has caused a variety of issues for the public.

Kieran Smith, Poole

Bring back British Rail.

Stan Hesketh, Wigan

Let’s bring sense back at last.

Sheila Lovett, Newton Abbot

Private companies have been ripping off the public for far too long.

Robert Lowery, Seaham

Enough of the experiment – it has comprehensively failed abysmally. Return the railroads to the customers.

Nik Walker, Preston

Bring it back where it belongs. To us.

Darrel Watson, London

East Coast is better now than it has been for years.

Timothy Wilson, Dundee