Yes, keep the mega-profits in this country. Come on – it makes sense.

Oak Weld, Colchester

East Coast contributes to the national wealth, while the other rail companies just take subsidies and make private profit.

Philip Cole, Barnsley

I never thought I would utter these words but, having travelled by Virgin and South West Trains, Bring BR back.

William Russell, London

We need cheaper, people-friendly fares not company fares. If we go back to state ownership of railways with British Rail everyone should have a better outcome.

Joshua Langstaff, Driffield

It’s long overdue. The present situation is ridiculous.

Tim Coad, Frodsham

Re-nationalise rail, power, mail and all other industries privatised by government, especially the Tory’s selfish greedy millionaires.

Kevin Doherty, Dumbarton

I would really like to be an active member and see the return of public rail services. I have travelled thousands of miles under private rail and public rail.

Richard Aspin, Blackburn

I left BR in 1995 after 18 years service, as I could see bad things happening because the changes that were made after privatisation (Potters Bar, Hatfield.)

Paul Gardener, Wallasey

The franchise system isn’t working. We need proper trains with enough coaches so that people can travel in comfort and at reasonable prices.

John Robinson, Lincoln

Before our national rail system becomes exclusively only for the rich and famous, re-nationalise it for affordable travel for everyone.

Steven Peacock, Chelmsford

It’s the best way to run a unified national system. Profitable segments can support an improved rural network. Beeching never intended that all those lines be closed.

Laurence Dickie, Brighton

We can make this work.

Guy Birkin, Nottingham

We should not allow our important infrastructure to be at the mercy of commerce.

John Gregory, Newcastle-upon-Tyne

It makes total sense.

Nick West, London

Set train fares at pence per mile. National railcard will bring a third off the price of the journey.

Andrew Wetherall, Ashford, Middlesex

No to private ownership.

Thomas Lynch, Newcastle-upon-Tyne

Give it back: you’ve mucked it up.

James Mackay, Glasgow

BR worked and worked well. Stations would help each other rather than compete.

Guy Foster, Pickering

The terrible prices are forcing Mr Average off rail and into the car.

Peter Dean, Plymouth

Bring back British Rail.

Debra Norgate, Dewsbury

This should be affordable for everyone and not just the rich.

Aaron Fry, Plymouth

Save our railway.

Paul Owenson, Nottingham

Profit before people – look at the awful First service – extortionate and rubbish. Fine for those who can afford it, but the majority of us are being robbed.

Matthew Dawson, Kirkwall

Re-nationalise and invest in a national rail service.

Nicola Shepherd, Alton

We need better regulated fares and to be treated as ‘passengers’, not ‘customers’. Also better choice of rolling stock (no more Pendolinos.)

Jonathan Paul, Gloucester

Oh for a bit of joined-up thinking and long-term planning. Never, with our daft political system.

Ian McMillan, Liphook

The lies about whether trains are on time or not need to be highlighted as an issue, as, apparently, the train companies manipulate the figures they put out about this.

Darrin Green, Horsham

These prices do not relate to the terrible service we are receiving.

A Motta, London

Bring back BR now for everyone’s sake.

Alan McVitty, Welwyn Garden City