State ownership of railways is much more efficient, as shown by the massive improvements all round when some franchises have been briefly state run recently.

John Thompson, London

Private organisations don’t always run things better.

Rob Shields, Sunderland

British Rail was a public asset which has been given to private companies to exploit to make profit. Bring it back into public ownership now.

Billie Reynolds, Reading

I love the idea! But the BR logo is wrong way round.

Henry Allum, Gerrards Cross

Enough is enough. Rail users first.

Simon Gee, Coventry

Give us back some of our family jewels.

Edward Luigi, Portsmouth

Time to do something about the railways. What about an integrated transport system running on nationally produced electricity from British coal?

David Hart, Chesterfield

The people of the British Isles require a nationalised rail service which brings affordable transport to its people.

Johnny Gomes, Sudbury

My other half works for a subcontractor for Network Rail and is mistreated and unhappy with how they are treated both in and out of work.

Carrie Machin, Stoke-on-Trent

Expensive, unreliable, worn out stock, needs central control across the board. Take away from the franchisees who are only interested in their bottom line.

Elaine Whybrow, Dartford

The whole rail system is a mess. Bring back British Rail.

Peter Worth, Nottingham

Return railways into public hands, so that profits can be returned to the railways to improve services rather than the money going to shareholders.

Allen Teare, Bishop Auckland

Our country deserves a national rail service, subsidised as necessary from the taxes I pay – a good use of my money.

Chrissie Chadney, St Albans

Even that bitch Margaret Thatcher thought it was a step too far.

William Smith, Newcastle-under-Lyme

The present ridiculous situation has gone on too long.

Anthony Thompson, Shepshed

Is it really going to make a difference or help the elderly with their travel? Let’s hope so.

Josie Matthews, Nottingham

All the train companies employ an army of people whose sole purpose is to argue about the attribution of delays – not to improve performance, just to save money.

Phil Simpson

We need to encourage more people to use public transport. This won’t happen whilst the railways are run for private profit.

Greg Phillips, Bristol

I think public transport is too important to be run by profiteers.

Jim Ennis, Wallasey

All the evidence shows utilities should not be run for profit.

Ian Latham, Doncaster

The only way that the railway works is to re-nationalise it. Put passengers before profit.

Jennifer Gray, Bristol

Worsening services for more and more money.

J De Haart, London

Bring BR back to public ownership, control fares and get more freight onto the railways.

Graham Donaldson, Wakefield

It should never have been privatised.

Mark Williams, Alderley Edge

British Rail – the clue is in the name. Network Rail and the private rail companies should be under one organisation.

Lyn Mackfall, Doncaster

My dad was always an instinctive Tory, but the rush to privatisation in the 80s onwards turned him Labour but not quite as far left as me. I would nationalise all public services.

John Hinchliffe, Leeds

I totally agree. Not because the old BR was brilliant, but because it can be.

Peter Nicholls, Stoke-on-Trent

An excellent idea. Here’s hoping.

Andrea Chapman, London

I’m a signaller for 35 years. Re-nationalise to prevent the madness of hundreds of companies working against each other.

Chris Hogg, Melton Mowbray

First East Coast trains and now Eurostar. What asset will be next?

William Dickson, Grangemouth