The time has come for us to return to a joined-up rail system.

Timothy Bell, Newcastle-upon-Tyne

Yes, I agree to the re-forming of good old British Rail.

Alan Pattison, Manchester

Why change a management team that works and makes a profit?

Carolyn Clift, Leeds

All the rail network should be nationalised.

Daphne Hayden, Whitley Bay

I pay for a cheaper train even though it stops at a further station than the place I need to go to. Logic.

Saneet Bhella, Leeds

Why is it cheaper to travel by car than by train?

Philip Quinton, Aylesbury

We need this.

Adam Fisher, York

I’ve been on the railways for ten years and the level of service has gone down. They shouldn’t have been sold off as they should be for the people not private profit.

Peter Alderton, Gravesend

My late father worked for BR and Rail Track and always moaned about how bad things had got after the take over, about penny-pinching mend-and-make-do and poor management.

Leslie Holder, Reading

Bring service industries back to their natural home – the public sector.

Mike Campbell, Durham

What we need now is a return of British Rail, in whatever form it may take, to get everything back under one roof.

Brian Racher

Do away with private regional rail networks.

Bill Hobson, Morden

Labour force mobility enriches the economy, and depends on affordable transport. The railway re-nationalisation process, which is already under way, needs completing now.

David Holt, Manchester

Privatisation was the easy way out for Margaret Thatcher – along with selling off council houses. Then energy. Now we are owned by multi-nationals. Give back our transport.

Catherine Vickery, Market Harborough

Private rail is expensive and inefficient, robbing the tax-payers.

George Bell, Gateshead

The Tories won’t do it but why didn’t Labour?

Roger Wells, Stourbridge

I’m sick of getting ripped off.

John Morrow, Sunderland

I’m just fed up with rip-off Britain and private fat cats getting rich on public assets. Why do we still subsidise them?

Peter Nunn, Polegate

Private interests should not profit from national infrastructure or a national service or a national utility at the expense of the public.

Edward Freeman, Dundee

It must make more sense to have one railway system run for the public good – transporting people for leisure and work is something for the government to be proud of.

Sarah Dignan, Preston

There would be less of a north/south divide if people could afford to visit other areas in the UK. It will benefit all communities across the nation.

Joseph Till, London

Power to the commuters and not the shareholders. Currently all profits go to shareholders and not back into the railway. It’s so subsidised it might as well be re-nationalised.

Ian Broadbent, Bristol

The train operating companies are fleecing taxpayers and the government.

Una-Jane Winfield, London

We need rail travel to be cheaper than going by car. That would be true step forward.

Simon Kingston, Wolverhampton

Do not share details with third parties.

Luis Galindo, Brighton

British Railways are awesome.

Emily Hallam, Nottingham

The privatisation of BR has brought no benefits, high fares, and still the public subsidise the service to a higher level than when it was in public ownership.

Richard Ineson, Whitby

As a child and in a family of four children, my parents frequently took us by train from Sandy, Bedfordshire to London Kings Cross.

Christine Chapman, Manchester

The tax-paying community is paying substantially for a failed privatised system. Rail communication benefits the whole society and should be re-nationalised to reflect this.

Diane Madeley, Abergavenny