I’m sick of standing only trains at peak time after the companies fail to put the right number of coaches on with no explanation.

Kate Steaggles, Southampton

Lower prices, customer centric and better integrated. Not much to ask in an OECD economy, right?

Nicole Fekete, Lincoln

Having a publicly-owned transport network (railways and coaches) is essential to the welfare of a nation. The needs of the public should be the priority.

Sam Satyanadhan, Southampton

Please re-nationalise British Rail services.

Katherine Stansfield, Frinton on Sea

British Rail wasn’t perfect but at least you understood the ticket pricing and a single was cheaper than a return.

Elizabeth Richardson, Milton Keynes

The current system just does not work.

Oliver Bowen, Abergavenny

However bad BR was, nothing can match the horror of the Southern Rail service. It must stop.

Rona Hunnisett, Cheam

Actually, I have lived in Norway for 37 years and the railways here are still (almost entirely) publicly owned and are very good.

Charles Andrew Rose, London

An efficient reliable customer-orientated rail service plus effective freight transport is what is needed.

Gillian Wolff, Sheffield

A properly-run rail network is essential to the economy of this country.

David Roberts, Stockport

I want the service I pay for! Is that too much to ask for?

Stuart Smith, Wigan

In spite of the evidence of the East Coast line thriving under public control, the Tories intend to flog it off to their mates.

Terry Weldon, Basildon

Private rail simply means private monopolies, and monopolies subsidised by the state.

Jonathan Brind, Chatham

No to private profiteers.

Mark Bretel, Birmingham

The current franchise agreements mean that profits can be sucked away from the railways by private companies, yet the government then has to stump up money for investment.

Peter Dickinson, Brierley Hill

British Rail.

Francis Goy, Retford

People before profit.

Roger Drury, Coleford

We’re now suffering from all the privatisation programmes from the 80s Tory era. Bring back nationalisation of them all. Rail, oil, energy companies. And the rest.

Ann Love, Pembrokeshire

What can I say, really?

Steven Gergus, Bolton

Railways should be run for the benefit of passengers not profits to line the pockets of fat cat directors.

Greg McLean, Falkirk

For the sake for of the environment, and because the railways should be a service not a money machine.

Julie Wilkinson, Stockport

5 times higher fare than anywhere in Europe. Outrageous to say the very least.

Jane Allely, Barry

The money earned from an integrated system should be used to invest in government and the railways themselves instead of lining the pockets of shareholders.

Sven Hanson, Brighton

Put it right. Like everything else, capitalism has gone so so wrong.

Vincent Morris

Any profit paid to shareholders is paid for by the taxpayer and by rail users paying high ticket prices. This can’t be right.

Christopher Black, Illogan

Terrible idea when they did it, and even worse now.

Justin Rivett, Taunton.

Intuitively I support private enterprise – but it only works where genuine competition exists, and that is clearly not the case with rail, where there is no alternative.

Andrew Lynch, Orpington

What is wrong with public services for the public as opposed to selling valuable institutions and infrastructure to private companies beholden to profit and shareholders?

Marion Clement, Edinburgh

Save us from these money-hungry men.

Joe Cruise, Chesterfield