We have the most subsidised railway and the highest fares – all to feed private profit. That’s madness.

Ken Kirk, Brighton

I travel from Chatham Station to London St Pancras International at an ever increasing fare and nothing extra for it. I cannot see where the money is going other than dividends.

Daniel Crouch, Rochester

It’s much better to have the government running the rail system for the good of the country and not shareholders.

Jean Berry, Nottingham

The privatisation of BR was a politically motivated scorched earth policy. It provides very bad value for taxpayers and should be reversed.

Michael Armstrong, Thirsk

We have such a poor service for the ridiculous price we pay. If something is a national service, it should not be private. It’s as simple as that.

David Netherwood

Fragmented, profit before service, this proposal is long overdue.

John Bostock, Swadlincote

The railways should be publicly run, publicly accountable, with profits ploughed back into the industry, not lining shareholders’ pockets.

Philip Blanksby, Derby

Since BR was privatised by the government it is now run by different companies. These companies hike up the fares every year and provide a poor service for high prices.

Eirug Griffiths, Neath

It is time to bring back the railways and put profit back into the economy instead if it going into fat cat pockets.

Peter Schofield, Barnsley

We need to bring British Rail as well as the rest of the UK infrastructure into public ownership.

Edward Wilson, Chediston

A general strike is the only way we can halt the erosion of our public national services.

Tim Wilson, Gateshead

Track, facilities, rolling stock and staff should be managed regionally, with overall direction from the centre.

Geoffrey Crouch, Cranbrook

Bring back British Rail – it belongs to the people not private business.

Paul Cope, Hayling Island

Prices are too high and conditions are poor, exploiting the day-to-day worker. They should be ashamed.

Bethan Harrison, London

The worst service since the great days of BR Southern Region.

Alan Bettridge, London

An efficient and affordable train service is vital for the economic well-being of the country.

Nicholas Burman-Vince, London

Unification is the only logical and efficient way to bring mass rapid passenger transit into the 21st century.

Fiona Potter, Billericay

Free the railway.

Paddy Cawkwell, Doncaster

As London gets more expensive to live in, more and more of us will have to commute, but £3,000-5,000 a year is totally ludicrous.

Mary Greer, London

Privatisation is theft of publicly owned infrastructure, transferred at knock-down prices to the already wealthy, at the expense of the people.

B Freeman, Stevenage

All privatisation does is create multimillionaires at taxpayers’ expense. Halting direct services because they encroach on other franchise areas is a disgrace.

Edward Moss, Manchester

The sooner the better.

Colin Fallows, Scarborough

I cannot afford to use public transport – it’s so expensive, so where is the money going? I have to use my car like most people have instead of the pollution-reducing train.

David Mercer, Morecambe

Obscurantist pricing, overcrowding, frequent late-running and cancellations are unacceptable. Private rail is a farce, a confidence trick and shameful.

Jeremy Abram, Taunton

We need investment in new trains. Why would a company with no long term guarantee of keeping its contract invest in new stock?

Diane Green, Huddersfield

British Rail was not perfect, but far, far better than the shower running the trains now.

Dominic Corby, London

Privatisation does not save money – I’ve been outsourced from a civil servant job and it is a fact that it costs more from private industry.

David White, Bicester

Profits made on the railways, as on the East Coast, should go back into government funds to enable improvements, not to shareholders.

Linda Gibbon