Privatisation has failed, as it seems do in most public services.

Melvyn Dalley, Sheffield

You know it makes sense, along with public ownership of gas, electricity and water. And while we are on the subject why not motor insurance?

David Motta, Folkestone

Private means profit. Railways should be run for the people not profit.

Connor Nightingale , Huddersfield

I am tired of being late for work, late getting home, waiting nervously for trains at unmanned stations, and having no toilets or waiting rooms open on a cold night.

Donna Ainsworth, Leatherhead

Re-nationalise the railways. They are for transport for all of the nation and should be nationally owned.

Barry Wilkinson, Aldershot

If only Miliband had some guts and re-nationalised the whole shebang of former public industries.

David Abbott, France

The exaggerated expense of tickets makes cost of travel into London unwieldy, impractical and expensive for those too poor to afford such services.

Joshua Flynn, Chelmsford

East Coast Line is the model railway outfit for all UK rail.

Paul White, Huddersfield

All essential services should be nationalised. That’s rail, water, energy, post office, and schools under local authority control.

Sylvia Coles, Nottingham

We need to restore the railway network to the commons.

Norman Fellows, Confolens, France

The East Coast line proves that public ownership works.

Steve Lucas, Surbiton

The railways are in desperate need of being re-nationalised as the privatisation of the railways has caused a variety of issues for the public.

Kieran Smith, Poole

Railways were privatised so why is the government spending £50bn to build a new line only to hand it over to a private operator for the benefit of a few people?

Mark Waterer, Ashford

The railways should be for people, not private profit.

Margaret Berry, Nottingham

The railways should never have been privatised. It’s all about looking after shareholders and not passengers. Fares are ridiculously expensive and overcrowding worse.

Mark McCabe, Glasgow

We need proper services, proper pricing which is comprehensible and trains that are affordable and usable. I would use a train to commute to work if I could.

Carolyn Mayfield, Okehampton

We want our public transport service back. We still pay for it in taxes.

Eira Short, Rochdale

The scandal of penalties which load the dice against Railtrack in favour of train operating companies.

Dave Wilson, Harlow

Intercity, the first profitable BR sector and envy of the world unmercifully butchered first. Bring back British Rail.

Alex Southern, London

Train services should not be run for private profit.

Carol Canning, High Wycombe

Let us all have our railways back in public ownership. A Labour government might help.

Nigel Dallison, Anglesey

We must get rid of this totalitarian neo-liberal philosophy. Railways are a social necessity and cannot successfully be ‘owned’ by private individuals for profit.

Nik Allday, Boston

Let the railways be run for the passengers and not for the shareholders.

Louise Ffoulkes, London

Car culture is killing our planet.

Brian Hutton, Dundee

As an ex-employee of British Rail, I can honestly say it was a pleasure to work hard and to serve the public. Re-nationalise now.

Ian Young, Hexham

East Coast Trains proved that public ownership works. How ridiculous to then sell it.

Gala Middleton, Newark

The railway system should be a service, an essential part of the country’s network, which is necessary for good communication.

Pat Brennan, Derby

Railway workers and users together to fight for our interests.

Steve Revins, Birmingham

Our train network is vastly inferior to that of any other major European country, and is an embarrassment.

Sebastian Hall, London

Privatisation only lets ministers obtain public funds to line their pockets.

Leighton Lewis, Aberdare